To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Heating Irregular Attached Garage

huntfish4ever

Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2013
Messages
7
My home has two attached garages that total ~1130 sq ft. The two garages are separated by a wall that has opening in it (5 foot wide and 7.5 foot tall). I want to put a heater in garage 2 (which doesn't share a wall with the house.). The heater will be used to try and keep both garages around 40-45 degrees in the winter. We live in central Iowa where winter temps can range from -10 to +30 degrees F. In addition, on occasion I may want to heat the garage to 65-70 degrees when working out there (oil changes, vehicle repairs / maintenance, cleaning deer, etc.). I will probably install a sliding 5' barn type door to isolate garage 2 when I will be working in only this area. Garage 1 is used primary to park a vehicle, but I would like to keep it close to the same temperature as garage 2 during the night to de-thaw the parked vehicle. I understand I have a bit off a bottleneck with only the 5 x 7 opening between the two garages. Opening can't be made larger without significant structural changes. My questions is how should I size this heater?

I was thinking along the lines of 75K reznor unit (UDAP-75 V3) to insure I could heat the entire space, but am starting to wonder if this will be over-sized. I am not worried about the little bit of extra initial cost, but want things to run efficiently and avoid problems that may be caused by short cycling. My plans are to install the heater in the upper left corner of garage 2, aimed directly at the 5' opening that adjoins garage 1.

I was also thinking about putting the heater on a programmable thermostat that will keep the garage heated during the evening / night to de-thaw the vehicles, but not run during during the weekdays when the garage sits empty (while we are at work).

Both garages will be well insulated (R19 in the walls). What level of insulation do you recommend above the ceiling. I was thinking about going ahead and insulating to R38.

Here is how the garages are laid out. You can see garage 1 shares a wall with the house and garage 2. Garage 2 shares only the wall with garage 1.

GarageHeatPlan.jpg
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
OP
H

huntfish4ever

Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2013
Messages
7
Bump. Some advice on proper sizing from someone who has a lot more experience with this type of thing would be greatly appreciated.

I have also had thoughts about wiring a fan mounted at the top of the 5 ft. Door opening to run when the heater's fan is running to help push heat into garage 1. Thoughts?
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Mattlt

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 30, 2005
Messages
1,383
Location
MN
I think the fan between the two garages is a really good idea. Not sure that you need to have it run only when the heater is running. Might be good to have it running nearly constantly. Especially when you're bringing in a very cold or very snow-covered vehicle. The moving air should help dry things out quicker.

I have a somewhat similar situation in my basement. I have a hydronic heater on one end that is fed from my outdoor wood boiler to provide some supplemental heat to the basement. That thing helps heat the rest of the basement despite the warm air having to go through a couple of doorways. I've never really tried, but I'm guessing a fan between rooms would make it even better.

As far as sizing the heater, I would size it for the whole area of the two garages. Again, as mentioned, cold vehicles, recovery time from opening garage doors, etc.

Strictly opinion. I have no idea what I'm doing. :)
 

kbs2244

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 11, 2006
Messages
14,065
Go to ceiling mounted IR heaters.
One for each room so you have control on a room for room basis.
Don't bother trying to circulate heated air.
There is no easy way with your set up.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom