is this a good deal or just regular price?
Craftsman 154 pc. Mechanics Tool Set, $89 after add to chart
http://www.kmart.com/shc/s/p_10151_10104_005W730703110001P
It's not a BAD deal, but it's not super-great.
The key (for me) on a lot of these Craftsman tool sets is to subtract the filler from the overall parts count, and then see how many pieces you get, and how much per-piece they are.
For smaller kits like this that have a lot of common stuff, I consider a "great deal" to be about $0.50/piece, with $0.60 - $0.70/piece a pretty common sale price.
For the mid-range to larger kits, $0.90 - $1.00/piece.
For the higher-end kits that have more specialty tools or "luxury" tools (like ratcheting wrenches or something), $1.00 - $1.30/piece is pretty good.
This kit is normally $149.99, which is $0.97/piece.
On sale, it's $99.99, which is $0.64/piece
The further discount to $89.99 renders it to be $0.58/piece.
My reasoning is that all of the stuff in the smaller kits is pretty common, it's available all the time on sale in one form or another. The socket range is common, the ratchets are the plain-jane workhorses, etc.
Subtract the filler, and you could probably buy all of that stuff separately during one sale or another for less than the price of the kit.
In the mid-range to high-end kits, you're getting more stuff that doesn't go on sale nearly as often, or isn't as widely available in other forms (kits, package deals, etc.)
So, revisiting my thought process above, we need to subtract 44 pieces from this kit - the Allen wrenches and the bits and bit driver. I'm not saying such things aren't handy to have, but they're not worth the "deal" price unless you don't already have something like that, and you REALLY want them. These are cheap filler pieces thrown in to inflate the piece count of the kit.
So, 111 pieces, $89.99 drives the price-per-piece back up to $0.81/piece. Definitely more palatable than $0.90/piece ($99.99) or $1.35/piece ($149.99), but still not "great deal".
Witness this kit:
http://www.sears.com/shc/s/p_10153_...0&redirectType=SKIP_LEVEL&prop17=933182#specs
Regular price is $229.99, it'll be on sale on Black Friday for $129.99. 182 pieces, woo! It comes with even more hex keys, so in this kit, 62 pieces are ****. In reality, it only has 9 pieces more than the 154 piece kit, after filler is subtracted. $1.08/pc. No deal.
It comes with 6 more sockets, 2 more wrenches and an extra ratchet extension over the 154 piece kit. It comes with a "nicer" or "better" tool box, instead of a blow-molded case, but that's really not worth the extra $30.
Now, this kit:
http://www.sears.com/shc/s/p_10153_12605_00933200000P?sid=IAx20071126x000001&aff=Y
Will be $99.99 on Black Friday. 128 sockets (vs. 93 sockets in the 154pc and 99 sockets in the 182pc).
Filler-subtracted, it's 138 pieces, so $0.72/piece. Not the biggest discount, but definitely a better price-per-piece than the other two.
They've got other bigger sets on sale for Black Friday as well. Traditionally, the bigger the set, the better the deal.