Good Lord people, the whole idea was to show how to make a cheap file handle. He didn't post it to get his chops busted for putting a file in a vise. Besides that, he didn't tighten the vise down that tight, and files are hard.
If doing that is going to ruin a file, and you know for a fact that it will ruin a file, post up a video showing how that file is ruined.
It always gets me that some people like the ideas, then her comes all the the other ones later telling the person they are wrong for showing that, yada, yada, yada.
Thanks for the support!
From my (OP) point of view, here is my feeling on the vise controversy.
While a couple good points have been made in this thread about the manner in which I attached the handle, almost all of the others have been misinformed. Saying a vise is going to "dull" or "ruin" a file is completely wrong.
1. The problem with that argument is the simple fact that the Brinell hardness rating of the file is much higher than the hardness rating of the mild-steel jaws in the vise. (Dont believe me? Try filing the jaws.) Because the file will score the surface of the jaws, the hardness is greater.
2. As a previous poster mentioned, files are very brittle.
This is precisely why I placed it into a vise. By placing it horizontally into the jaws, I was able to spread the force applied by closing it securely over a very large surface. (Think about walking across snow VS using snowshoes). Had I put it in the vise vertically, all the force would have been focused on a tiny section on the front and rear. I stopped tightening immediately upon the file becoming secure.
3. If you stand the file up and put one end on the bench, and tap the handle on the other end, the force WILL cause the file to snap in half. (Found this out the hard way). Without something to absorb the force....in my case the vise....the brittle file is very prone to failure.
4. I do agree that files stored together loosely against each other will dull prematurely. This is because they are all the same hardness rating!
5. Most expert opinions I encounter online are exactly that....opinions. From reading some of the more negative responses, I come to 2 conclusions. Either a LOT of really smart people here have wasted/damaged/dulled countless files by putting them in a vise before watching my video....or more likely, the read a post that sounded good, so they repeated it.
So, to some this all up.....
I like making videos to help people. I am sorry if I did something that you wouldn't, but just because you may have done it a different way, doesn't mean I am wrong.
*** Oh, and just for arguments sake, I examined my files with a magnifying glass to inspect for damage.....by some miracle, there was NONE! I compared them side-by-side with brand new ones I still had unopened & could not see any differences at all. ***
Thanks for watching!
Please subscribe!
Woodstockva