To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Siding options - Residential looking good on budget.

imjustdave

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 9, 2014
Messages
204
Location
Sumner WA
TLDR version.
1. How would you design siding for curb appeal especial on a BIG wall of a shop
2. Do you have any photos of shops that have more than grade to roof metal siding?
3. Ideas on how to fit in and hide a bigger than home shop in town.
4. ideas in general welcome.
5. Trying not to look like a pole barn - no offense to that look just not the goal I'm looking for.


Long version,
I'm trying to keep this short, here is my context.

I'm building a garage in a city - town. My lot that is just shy bigger than 20,000 SQ feet or about .45 acer. so not large by any stretch but decent sized for living in a city. Age of homes range from built yesterday to 40-50+ years old, it's a salt and pepper mix really of old and newer.

I live down a short, private road for 3 homes, so my neighbors are it for traffic.
My home was built in 2007 Rambler with 6:12 and 12:12 Hip roof construction. Neighbor between me and shop and across the street was built in 2001, Both 2 story typical construction for the area. But on the other side of me on the main road was built in 1950.

So I'm trying to stay within a reasonable budget "yes i'm trying to build as big as I can afford" but also look "right" in the neighborhood.

My lot actually looks like 2 lots from above, most people assume it's an empty lot but it isn't, so my garage will be my neighbor next to me VS behind.

I feel the bigger issue is the size of my shop, looking at 40 wide 50-60 deep But 14 foot tall door :3gears:. The front will have 2 garage doors and or 1 big bifold door. and then the 1 side facing the home will be 50-60 long with a man door and maybe a few windows. Plan is a 6:12 -5:12 gable roof to match the home somewhat. Setback from main home will be 30 ish feet, so it will be seen more then if it was a 5 foot setback like my neighbor will have.

Most siding in the area is Hardie, my home is a mix of Hardi and batten board above the peaked roof.

Question?

What siding would you use for such a large WALL area?

I see lots of FARM garages with big wall space and it's epic and non stop, not sure it fits into a residential feel and or feel that I want.
FYI T-111 is prohibited by code.

Yes Hardi was the first thought maybe 8 or 12 inch reveil but that is a lot of wall to run hardi on.

Wife wants to maybe see if we can do some stone work like the home, no clue how hard it would be to match up. Issue I see is the front will only have the space where no garage door is, so only a few feet and then we have the wall facing our home which is about 900 SQ feet of wall, I don't want a full wall of stone, assume it's $$$$ even in fake style.

Also thought maybe metal siding I actually like the look, speed and costs on install, and painting, and or to break up the wall some. AKA a mix.

FYI home needs painting and open to color changes.
Black asphalt roofing currently. shop thinking of running Black standing seam roof.

Photo have names in lower left to get an idea. First photo is my home.
 

Attachments

  • Mine.jpg
    Mine.jpg
    150.3 KB · Views: 91
  • Accross.jpg
    Accross.jpg
    150.4 KB · Views: 85
  • Nextdoor.jpg
    Nextdoor.jpg
    146.8 KB · Views: 80
  • Main.jpg
    Main.jpg
    147 KB · Views: 80
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

kbs2244

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 11, 2006
Messages
14,065
check the photo galley of some of the bi-fold door co.s
they show some ways to hide the size of the door.

https://www.bifold.com/photo-of-the-day-washington-rv-garage-door.php

a false front door, windows and dormers will do a lot to make the front look like a house.
when I built my shop next door to the house I told the crew if they had an appearance question and I wasns't around to just "match the house."
 
Last edited:

rayra

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 1, 2014
Messages
4,724
Location
Escaped from Los Angeles
I'd try to match the finish on the house, or at least the color. And I'd paint that huge door the same color as the walls. Both points to downplay the commercial / industrial look of the building. Maybe even color match your roof steel to your house roof color.
 
OP
I

imjustdave

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 9, 2014
Messages
204
Location
Sumner WA
check the photo galley of some of the bi-fold door co.s
they show some ways to hide the size of the door.

https://www.bifold.com/photo-of-the-day-washington-rv-garage-door.php

a false front door, windows and dormers will do a lot to make the front look like a house.
when I built my shop next door to the house I told the crew if they had an appearance question and I wasns't around to just "match the house."

Yeah ... I'm pretty sure I have read every page on bifold thus far... still undecided if I want to go that direction or just 2 large doors.

I'm ok with the door side to look like doors, it is a garage after all and that's ok. It will be set back 45-50 feet off of the street and the doors will break up that wall.

The concern is the big side wall. And what I can use that looks great but isn't going to cost me too much.
 
OP
I

imjustdave

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 9, 2014
Messages
204
Location
Sumner WA
I'd try to match the finish on the house, or at least the color. And I'd paint that huge door the same color as the walls. Both points to downplay the commercial / industrial look of the building. Maybe even color match your roof steel to your house roof color.

Well roof will be black like the home, asphalt or standing seam undecided. Solar eventually is in the plans. :willy_nil

Home needs new paint so home color won't be an issue, not fan of the color and it's time.

The biggest Q is Do I just match the siding "Hardi" and go for it. Or is there a product out there that is better that will blend in decently and add character.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

loganb

ALLIANCE MEMBER
Joined
Dec 29, 2011
Messages
5,606
Location
Omaha, NE
What direction will the street facing elevation you're concerned about face? With that sidewall height, you could easily put some windows up high to break up the wall and better fit the neighborhood without loosing prime wall real estate for storage or tools.

As long as its not a north facing elevation, should help bring in additional natural light as well



Sent from The Garage Journal mobile app
 

JamesW84

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 13, 2015
Messages
827
Location
Springfield, MO
I'm in the process of putting LP smartside on the front of my shop. Brick veneer on the bottom 4' around the 12x14 doors and then smartside all the way up. Metal panel siding on the rest.

They discontinued the smartside with the groove cut out in the back for aligning the laps, so maybe you could find some of that leftover on discount. I got mine from Menards a couple months ago...normally $14 and I think I paid $11 per 16' piece.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom