I recieved a Paulding Hammer (SN 44) as a gift from my wife for our 10th Anniversary. My wife had it personalized with my name and the date of our 10th annivesary, which I think was a very classy way to have it marked. A brass face was also included.
Regarding The Hammer, it's extremely well made and I'm very happy with it. John's done a nice job with overal design, getting the knurling right, the etching is immaculate, etc. I've used it very little so far as I've been traveling virtualy the whole time since I got it. The weight is very far up toward the business end, especially with the heavier faces (brass and steel). It is a unique and quality tool, sure to please even the snobbiest tool nut.
The quality of materials and selection of head materials is fantastic. The weight can also be adjusted by changing or removing heads.
The only negative to my review is with regard to the head faces. I forget if A_Pmech or any other posters have discussed this so excuse me if this is a feature vs. flaw topic:
The faces are perfectly straight and perpendicular to the head axis. The outside corner edges are not sharp, but nearly (especially on the steel head). If I were designing it, I'd put a more generous radius or chamfer (or better, a small radius into and out of a chamfer) on the outer edges of the faces. As is, it the edges could leave a mark on surfaces if the incoming blow is not perfectly perpedicular to the surface, which is dififult to always prevent. The current design gives a bigger, flatter striking surface but risks damaging softer surfaces. It also increases the risk of cutting a substrate if it were cloth, rubber, etc. Obviously it's more work to machine those features but that given the effort and precision going into the rest of the hammer, I think it'd be worth implementing a more gentle geometry on the edge faces. Even a simple radius form (.04?) would be a nice improvement.
I might be interested in ordering a slightly crowned head design as well as a full ball peen design in the future. That's the great thing about The Hammer, it's a fully customizable product.
Thanks for the Hammer, and keep up the good work!
Here are some pics: