To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Thoughts on an inexpensive sockets set

bpjr

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 2, 2013
Messages
554
Location
Florida east coast
No need to spend big bucks for this application. Just about any budget brand collection of tools will do a road side repair. I put 3 kits together for my cars that way, most are used but a couple socket sets were purchased at HF, Sears and Homedepot. The tool bags HF sells work well and hold more than needed.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
OP
N

nbpt100

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 19, 2016
Messages
2,301
Location
Massachusetts
Well I finally got to HF and with a $10 off coupon I picked up this kit and I must say I am fairly well satisfied for what it is and the cost. I know some will be put off by this Pittsburgh set but for occasional use I think it will work just fine I am not excited about the ratchets. They are not QR, but I have my own QR that I will put in a bag and may not use those in the set. For $30 the sockets and hard plastic case alone were worth it.
I also got the 8 pc Pro screw driver set and with the 20% off coupon they came to $8.
I may add a set of 3/8 drive metric deep sockets plus some extensions and I will have quite a bit covered.

https://www.harborfreight.com/64-pc-14-in-38-in-12-in-drive-sae-metric-socket-set-63461.html
 
OP
N

nbpt100

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 19, 2016
Messages
2,301
Location
Massachusetts
A Pittsburg Pro set would’ve been better for not much more money, but good luck to you.

I think you mean Quinn? I say that because I did not see any Pitts Pro sets that were even close to this. In this set all of the deep sockets and the 3 ratchets say Pittsburgh Pro on them. What ever that is worth.

The Quinn 66 pc set is what I saw as a similar offering in about the same case size in the next quality level up. No body will say it is not better quality but for something I will use maybe a few times a year, the Pittsburgh should work.
Also I noted the Quinn skips the 18mm and give you a 22mm instead. But the 22 is the same as 7/8. The extra two pcs are a 1/2 extension and a 13/16 spark plug socket.

This is a bit off topic but why do these sets that try to be compact or try to be economical duplicate effective sizes. i.e. you don't really need a 5/16 and the 8mm while the 3/4 and 19mm are effectively the same. They could then provide two more different sizes in the same foot print making it more versatile. I have never seen a set make this move.

https://www.harborfreight.com/66-pc-14-in-38-in-12-in-drive-sae-metric-hi-vis-socket-set-64267.html
 
Last edited:

cjarvis

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 30, 2017
Messages
359
This is a bit off topic but why do these sets that try to be compact or try to be economical duplicate effective sizes. i.e. you don't really need a 5/16 and the 8mm while the 3/4 and 19mm are effectively the same. They could then provide two more different sizes in the same foot print making it more versatile. I have never seen a set make this move.

Because MOST people don't realize this.
 

65k10

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 25, 2016
Messages
619
Location
somewhere
This is a bit off topic but why do these sets that try to be compact or try to be economical duplicate effective sizes. i.e. you don't really need a 5/16 and the 8mm while the 3/4 and 19mm are effectively the same. They could then provide two more different sizes in the same foot print making it more versatile. I have never seen a set make this move.

https://www.harborfreight.com/66-pc-14-in-38-in-12-in-drive-sae-metric-hi-vis-socket-set-64267.html

Once in a while I've seen wrench sets that sort of did this or had the idea in mind, but the only time I've really seen it implemented with sockets is this small portable set from Teng Tools.
https://tengtoolsusa.com/products/teng-tools-t3848-48-piece-3-8-inch-drive-metric-and-sae-tool-set
 
OP
N

nbpt100

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 19, 2016
Messages
2,301
Location
Massachusetts
Because MOST people don't realize this.

That is exactly why they should do it and advertise an advantage over those who waste space and don't provide as many sizes in the same footprint. I assume the marketing experts disagree.

Once in a while I've seen wrench sets that sort of did this or had the idea in mind, but the only time I've really seen it implemented with sockets is this small portable set from Teng Tools.
https://tengtoolsusa.com/products/teng-tools-t3848-48-piece-3-8-inch-drive-metric-and-sae-tool-set

This is a smart well thought out, space saving tool kit. But for $315 it should be.
 

measuredtwice

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 17, 2019
Messages
1,705
Location
USA
An elderly neighbor has the Stanley set from Walmart. I helped him put up some garage shelving and got a chance to use it. It is not the set from Canada that was shown earlier in the topic. It does have a lifetime warranty for those who are wondering about that. The blow molded case is nice as was previously mentioned. It's not like the GearWrench cases that are a jumbled mess when you open them. Everything fits very snuggly. Ratchet has 72 teeth.

I seriously doubt the $15 Harbor Freight set is better but the HF fanboys are the most vocal group on the forum. Recently someone even recommended Harbor Freight in response to a topic asking what to buy on Ebay during a coupon promotion. I do wonder if some of you guys are paid for the endorsements--haha.

With these cheap sets, I'd make sure everything fits together and works well. Better to check when you get it rather than to find out there's a problem when there's an emergency. My neighbor's set had a factory error and had to replace the 1/4 to 3/8 adapter.
 
Last edited:
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

snickers muncher

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 19, 2018
Messages
939
Location
Northeast GA
Yeah, I don't get the Stanley bashing either. I've got two Walmart Stanley sets that I picked up on clearance at different locations and times. The larger one (3/8 & 1/4) was used to do a timing belt on a car and the smaller one (3/8 with 1/4 sockets) is what I grab often if it's just a quick operation just because of its small case size. No skipped sizes in either. They've both proven to be decent sets. We're definitely not talking long term shop use, but they're certainly suitable for the occasional use by a homeowner or to throw in the trunk.
 
Last edited:

Nineeightyone

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 21, 2018
Messages
393
Location
Pennsylvania
Yeah, I don't get the Stanley bashing either. I've got two Walmart Stanley sets that I picked up on clearance at different locations and times. The larger one (3/8 & 1/4) was used to do a timing belt on a car and the smaller one (3/8 with 1/4 sockets) is what I grab often if it's just a quick operation just because of its small case size. No skipped sizes in either. They've both proven to be decent sets. We're definitely not talking long term shop use, but they're certainly suitable for the occasional use by a homeowner or to throw in the trunk.

I strongly considered one of these sets for a vehicle/AX bag loadout. A tool is only worth the job it completes, after all. I think that because the Stanley tools aren't marketed as a high-tier tool, they get a bad rap. But my experience with using them has been that they aren't awful, they're just not amazing.
 

Fluelikesymptoms

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 19, 2019
Messages
289
Location
Midwest snow belt
I strongly considered one of these sets for a vehicle/AX bag loadout. A tool is only worth the job it completes, after all. I think that because the Stanley tools aren't marketed as a high-tier tool, they get a bad rap. But my experience with using them has been that they aren't awful, they're just not amazing.



Is this thread still going?

I've said it multiple times here, I will say it agian. Some of you may have said you had good experiences with the walmart Stanley sets. I have had bad experiences with their tools, brand new.

I wouldnt say there amazing, I wouldnt say there awful either. I would say they are somewhere between extremely awful and a waste of commodities and labor expenses.
 
OP
N

nbpt100

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 19, 2016
Messages
2,301
Location
Massachusetts
Is this thread still going?

I've said it multiple times here, I will say it agian. Some of you may have said you had good experiences with the walmart Stanley sets. I have had bad experiences with their tools, brand new.

I wouldnt say there amazing, I wouldnt say there awful either. I would say they are somewhere between extremely awful and a waste of commodities and labor expenses.

Thanks for keeping it going. High volume manufactured tools will produce a few duds right out of the box. I am Sorry you had that experience. You hear similar stories on here, on Amazon and Ebay reviews etc. But you also hear positive stories about budget brand tools as well. Even from self identified professional mechanics. You all know the brands. It is a calculated risk you take weighing cost and how you plan to use them. Keeping everything in perspective. Why expect a Tool Truck tool to be the same as Pittsburgh, Stanley etc? It is not honest to go on line and try to argue they should be the same. I beat on some budget ratchet and it broke there fore it is a POS.

Did you try to warranty them? if so, what was your experience like.? Or did you just throw everything out and run to the tool truck out of frustration.?:)
 

Parrothead

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 27, 2014
Messages
5,346
Location
Earth
Lots of great comments. Many that confirm my thinking and some that are expanding my thinking. Ideas like getting a wrench roll with some common combo wrenches. Also Including some torx and hex bits. Torx are more common and needed to change some light bulbs.

...As more than one suggested it may be used for non auto applications. Why limit yourself for only a few dollars. You never know When you are helping someone fix their snow blower, lawn mower, or assemble a grill. What ever!

In my original post I just threw out a few possibilities that quickly came to my head. Who knows what it could be? Who knows what kind of car I will be driving in two years? It is all an educated guess to cover the basics...

...Lots of ways to go and lots of options. That 200 pc Husky set is a great deal...

...I love tools and I will likely buy more stuff than I set out to do. That is the danger of looking for ideas on the Garage Journal.

You’ve completely changed the parameters and with that the advice changes

I have 3 tool scenarios.

1) Emergency repair kit.
Consists of tools to do the job on the side of the road. I have stuff like radiator hose tape, wire, vice grips, and stuff for specific repairs.

2) Junkyard tool box.
Consists of any tools I’d need to remove anything I’d want. Pry bar, breaker bar, flip lug sockets, tin snips, sockets, trim removal tools, etc.

3) Travel tools.
Consists of a packed 3 drawer tool box and three 14” tool bags. I have pliers, wrenches, screwdrivers, and other mechanical tools in the box. In the bags I have everything from a multimeter, power tools, a caulk gun, a pipe wrench, and we’ll you get the idea. I have fishing trays with wire nuts, screws, nails, electrical tape, etc.. Zero of the travel tools are my home tools either. I take them to my father in laws farm, or his vacation home, or to my rental. I can just grab and go.

The reality is, unless you go with a real travel tool setup, you’re never going to be able to do everything you want for others.
 
OP
N

nbpt100

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 19, 2016
Messages
2,301
Location
Massachusetts
Thanks Parrot head. Good thoughts. My Junk yard tool box changes for each trip. I try to make it as light as I can get a way with as there is usually a lot of walking.
 

Downwindtracker 2

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 13, 2019
Messages
1,715
Location
BC
My truck box set was put together with the idea that I never wanted to have to use it. If read back on my posts, you'll see I've done a fair bit of work with it.

It was the second one I put together, the first was stolen. Much more of annoyance than a financial loss.
 

Fluelikesymptoms

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 19, 2019
Messages
289
Location
Midwest snow belt
Did you try to warranty them? if so, what was your experience like.? Or did you just throw everything out and run to the tool truck out of frustration.?:)

I threw them out and ran to sears in frustration.

Keep in mind I was 16 during this experience with their tools, and I've never purchased them since. That was over 10 years ago.

The most experience I've had with their cheap sets is when I am visiting someone and they ask me to fix something and pull out a ratchet set from their closet. Doesmt seem like the quality has improved one bit
 
Last edited:

CoogarXR

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 11, 2016
Messages
6,852
Location
Ohio
I didn't read all 5 pages, but my road box consists of all the tools that were rotated out of my main box. So I buy a new socket set, the old one gets demoted to road duty. So instead of buying a mediocre set on purpose, buy a better set for your main box and demote whatever is currently in there ;)
 

mfewtrail

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 14, 2011
Messages
675
I have a Stanley(Bostitch) set that I've been using almost exclusively at home the past four years when I need hand tools. Everything has held up great. Not a fan of the laser etching(it wears easily), but it's not that big of a deal if you keep the tools in the case since it's also labeled.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom