To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

USA made Ratcheting Box Wrenches

sign216

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 24, 2017
Messages
60
Location
Taunton, Massachusetts
I am in the market for some ratcheting Sae box wrenches. I want to go made in America, but it looks like the only place that still makes those here is Snap-on.

Are there any American makers left that are a little friendlier to my wallet?

Joe
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

General Geoff

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 12, 2013
Messages
3,875
Location
Allentown, Pennsylvania
Geoff, Proto's current ratchet wrenches are reportedly made in Taiwan. (At least it's an Amer. Ally).
The specific type that I linked is USA-made. They also sell Taiwan-made wrenches. The distinct beam style of the USA wrenches makes them easy to tell apart.

20171022002829-4d73f459-xl.jpg



These are the Taiwan-made ones:

 

jsmeece

Well-known member
Joined
May 17, 2017
Messages
544
Location
Kanawha County, West Virginia
Are you looking for combination ratcheting wrenches or box wrenches? All the pictures posted in this thread so far are combination ratcheting wrenches not box wrenches.

I have Armstrong box wrenches in SAE and metric, they are made in USA. However, Armstrong is no more. Sets can be found on Ebay, just be aware if you go this route there will be no warranty.
 

02camaro86

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 20, 2014
Messages
310
Location
New Jersey
Holy @#$_+, I checked the SK version, and the seller reports it's made in Taiwan.
i wouldnt buy the xframes, i had to warranty 3 wrenchs twice in 2yrs, in addition they are large, have no offset and are 6point. i really cant believe how much i DIDNT like to use them. i sold the complete sae and metric set hardly with holders (including the 3 brand new replacements) for $380 shipped. sold in like 20 mins on ebay. guess they were priced right. bought used snap on and im much happier
 
Last edited:

Boogerman

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 28, 2021
Messages
833
Location
aspen cove hill
Have Proto USA like General Geoff, SAE & Metric. Have also Snap on. Like Proto, slightly more like Snap on, but double price. Buy Proto at ZORO, see hot deals thread for discount codes help price.
 

89MustangGX

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 24, 2008
Messages
1,023
Location
Stanwood, WA
Are you looking for combination ratcheting wrenches or box wrenches? All the pictures posted in this thread so far are combination ratcheting wrenches not box wrenches.

I have Armstrong box wrenches in SAE and metric, they are made in USA. However, Armstrong is no more. Sets can be found on Ebay, just be aware if you go this route there will be no warranty.
I have a set of the Armstrongs and I also have a set of Matcos, which are rebranded Armstrongs - they are exactly the same. If you are concerned with warranty, Matco is still marketing a made-in-Taiwan set that I understand they would warranty a made-in-USA set for. The Taiwan versions are 90-tooth and look nearly identical and are probably really nice as well. HOWEVER, I will point out that if used "correctly" I don't think you would ever have a warranty issue. Use the fixed box-end to break the fastener loose, then flip the wrench and ratchet it off. And vise-versa for tightening. Minimal stress on the ratchet itself.

Pointing this out because they are for sure my favorite wrenches and they do come up on eBay from time to time, sometimes even NOS sets, and they will fall in the same/similar price range.

BTW, Apex will warranty the Armstrongs, but they will send out one of the XL Gearbox wrenches as a replacement. Not nearly the same (I bought a broken one to try this out and this was my result).

qqh67ql24ua41.jpg
 
Last edited:

jsmeece

Well-known member
Joined
May 17, 2017
Messages
544
Location
Kanawha County, West Virginia
I have a set of the Armstrongs and I also have a set of Matcos, which are rebranded Armstrongs - they are exactly the same. If you are concerned with warranty, Matco is still marketing a made-in-Taiwan set that I understand they would warranty a made-in-USA set for. The Taiwan versions are 90-tooth and look nearly identical and are probably really nice as well. HOWEVER, I will point out that if used "correctly" I don't think you would ever have a warranty issue. Use the fixed box-end to break the fastener loose, then flip the wrench and ratchet it off. And vise-versa for tightening. Minimal stress on the ratchet itself.

Pointing this out because they are for sure my favorite wrenches and they do come up on eBay from time to time, sometimes even NOS sets, and they will fall in the same/similar price range.

BTW, Apex will warranty the Armstrongs, but they will send out one of the XL Gearbox wrenches as a replacement. Not nearly the same (I bought a broken one to try this out and this was my result).

qqh67ql24ua41.jpg
My 8mm is Matco, I could not find an 8mm Armstrong so I bought the Matco.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

javyLSU

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 2, 2019
Messages
1,542
Location
New Haven, CT
The specific type that I linked is USA-made. They also sell Taiwan-made wrenches. The distinct beam style of the USA wrenches makes them easy to tell apart.

20171022002829-4d73f459-xl.jpg



These are the Taiwan-made ones:

It's also worth noting that the USA-made Proto ratcheting wrenches are spline drive - some people don't care for that, and prefer 12-point. Just wanted the OP to be aware in case these are being considered.
 

mhejl

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 7, 2015
Messages
328
Location
DFW Texas
I have Proto USA made sets (linked above) in both SAE and Metric. They're spline drive, relatively short, and rather bulky with a rectangular beam that is barely rounded on the corners.

The Proto beams bothered me enough to get the Snap-On Metric set. I don't use SAE enough to justify replacement with SO. I still have the Proto Metrics as backup but probly should just sell them. Somehow, I lost the roll for the metric set but still have the roll for the SAEs.
 

Under_Pressure

Well-known member
Joined
May 13, 2014
Messages
114
Location
NE Wisconsin
Not to be pedantic, but in this case it's not so much a matter of being "still" made in the US- ratcheting wrenches (as we currently know them- not the open sided laminated ones) are a tool that has really no US manufacturing history. I believe it was a tool born in Taiwan, and that has traditionally been where the high quality ones have come from. Now of course many of them, including the OG Gearwrench, have moved to lower cost China. The companies that have made US versions- Snap On, Proto, and SK- have done it specifically because they know there is a "US or bust" contingent that is willing to pay a significant premium for a US made tool and/or (particularly in Proto's case I imagine) to satisfy certain contractual requirements for certain customers. My point is that the traditional home for high-quality ratcheting wrenches is Taiwan, so while I also would take US made if possible (and I do have X Frames) this is one of those tools where I wouldn't really feel bad at all about going with Taiwanese made either.

And on the SKs, as far as I know any X Frames are going to be US made. I think SK did at one time offer another line of ratcheting wrenches that were Taiwan sourced, but that was before they doubled down on their ******** "100% US made" campaign of the past several years, which seemed to be Ideal's strategy for the brand.
 

BigLeagueSmoes

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 10, 2022
Messages
314
Location
Central IL
Are you looking for combination ratcheting wrenches or box wrenches? All the pictures posted in this thread so far are combination ratcheting wrenches not box wrenches.

I have Armstrong box wrenches in SAE and metric, they are made in USA. However, Armstrong is no more. Sets can be found on Ebay, just be aware if you go this route there will be no warranty.
I also have SAE and Metric Armstrong ratcheting wrenches, both double box end and open end/box end combination. Made in USA. High quality in my opinion. Like jsmeece said, no longer made but still around on eBay

 

corn chip

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 15, 2021
Messages
672
best i can tell ,95% of ratcheting wrenches are taiwan. remaining 5% is usa ,china ,germany and maybe czech republic. even big names like stahwille are rebranding taiwan stuff which seems suprising to me
 

KnurledNut

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 28, 2011
Messages
8,152
Location
n/a
Williams!!!! Last I checked these are made in the US


Williams Supercombo reversible ratcheting set would be my recommendation.

WS-1170RCU​

https://protoolwarehouse.com/3-8-3-...ation-ratcheting-wrench-set-7-pcs-ws-1170rcu/
17c138c2e4feb03f.png

These are forged and assembled in the US. However the mechanism is imported. Its the same as the Williams/Bluepoint/CAT mechanism manufactured by Cendai in Taiwan.
 

designer485

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 12, 2010
Messages
547
Location
Orange County, CA
These are forged and assembled in the US. However the mechanism is imported. Its the same as the Williams/Bluepoint/CAT mechanism manufactured by Cendai in Taiwan.
The must have taken the gen one 72 tooth Snap-On design and sent it overseas because they look identical to my USA made Snap-On gen one set. Good to know however. It doesn't change my opinion on it though, they are very nice wrenches and the beam on Supercombo's is one the best i have held. The Taiwan made Williams ratcheting wrenches are also very well made and work great.

i-gxP38pD.jpg

i-cQTx4gJ.jpg
 

KnurledNut

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 28, 2011
Messages
8,152
Location
n/a
The must have taken the gen one 72 tooth Snap-On design and sent it overseas because they look identical to my USA made Snap-On gen one set. Good to know however. It doesn't change my opinion on it though, they are very nice wrenches and the beam on Supercombo's is one the best i have held. The Taiwan made Williams ratcheting wrenches are also very well made and work great.

Or the Snap-on isnt completely USA made, even though it met the % requirement for COO. :yikes:
Anyways...

1644617340969.jpeg

1644617388312.jpeg
 

JradM

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 4, 2019
Messages
1,817
Location
Alberta
The spline-drive Protos... spline drive's reputation is worse than it merits.

The "problem" is that spline drive can accommodate a wider size variance in fastener head than 12pt - which manufacturers caught onto and decided to make them "universal" drive. I.e. they intentionally make them loose fitting and then market them as fitting either metric or SAE. Don't buy those.

On the other hand, the Taiwanese-made black-finish spline-drive reversible ratcheting combination wrenches are my favorite ratcheting wrenches. They're excellent!

The chrome I-beam USA-made wrenches are very bit as well-made, I just prefer the feel of the black ones.
 

General Geoff

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 12, 2013
Messages
3,875
Location
Allentown, Pennsylvania
The spline-drive Protos... spline drive's reputation is worse than it merits.
Agreed. My most-often used 3/8 socket set is spline drive, and it's not even made anymore. I wish it was because they're awesome. The set was offered back when Facom owned SK, in fact it comes with a Facom-style ratchet (but still says USA on it).

20220116_233157.jpg
 

Firebrick43

Well-known member
Joined
May 12, 2015
Messages
14,071
Location
West central Indiana
The first gen snap on and the Williams (exact same mechanism) had the ratchet parts made in Taiwan. I had the snap on one and used the 9/16 one all the time as there is a lot of 3/8” bolts on cat engines.

the only problem with the first gen is the selector is prone to falling off when the screw backs out and you don’t notice it. I broke the little tang off once to. I have warrentied that wrench maybe 6 times in the last 15 years. They sent me the second gen last time maybe 5 years ago? And it is much more robust, all made in the USA and unfortunately a little fatter in the thighs.
 

shakenfake

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 16, 2023
Messages
609
Location
Shlumpt, TX
Bringing this thread back from the dead because I am doing some research on USA made ratcheting wrenches. I only need a couple that I am missing (7/8s and an offset 9/16s). I think I would like to avoid the dog bone style to match the rest of my wrenches.

Williams seems to be made in TWN according to all the sites I try and buy it from even though it has a USA stamp. I am going to send them an email though and find out more. Proto's site blows and I don't want spline drive. Is Snap-On really the only option here?
 

shawhite

Well-known member
Joined
May 28, 2014
Messages
1,519
I guess it would depends on exactly what you are looking for 7/8 0 offset or 15 degree, reversible or non? If you are looking for a 0 offset 7/8 non reversible snap-on is your only option for made in USA as far as I’m aware. If you want 7/8 15 degree offset reversible. There is no made in the USA offer. 9/16 both Williams and snapon.
 

shakenfake

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 16, 2023
Messages
609
Location
Shlumpt, TX
@shawhite Sorry, I should have clarified. 7/8" does not need to be offset. Williams does offer a 7/8" non reversible (I don't really care or have a preference on this part) but I am waiting to hear back on MiUSA for that. The 9/16" does need to be offset and I would consider a flex head for this. Flex heads are all Taiwan offerings it seems unless there are German/Euro options, but that would be another thread.
 

Wamsutta

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 8, 2014
Messages
10,878
Location
Amarillo, Texas
Bringing this thread back from the dead because I am doing some research on USA made ratcheting wrenches. I only need a couple that I am missing (7/8s and an offset 9/16s). I think I would like to avoid the dog bone style to match the rest of my wrenches.

Williams seems to be made in TWN according to all the sites I try and buy it from even though it has a USA stamp. I am going to send them an email though and find out more. Proto's site blows and I don't want spline drive. Is Snap-On really the only option here?

Yes and just remember there's the SOXR series and the OXR series. The OXR series will have a nice smooth open end without the teeth.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom