To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Why Buy Snap-on?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Bruce57

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 16, 2014
Messages
323
Location
Central Ohio
My first mechanic's job was in a motorcycle shop. I had some Craftsman tools but the shop owner insisted only Snap-on tools be used. His position was nothing would leave the shop looking like it had been worked on (in other words, repairs needed to look like they were original new parts - rounding the edge of fasteners was not an option). He showed me how much better the Snap on wrenches and sockets fit fasteners than my Craftsman did. This has always stuck with me and was a good lesson on quality work and pride in workmanship. I like Snap on tools - the quality, fit, and finish. Yes, there are other good quality tools, and I am well aware good tools do not make a good mechanic. I don't buy everything Snap-on, they do a lot of things well, but not everything. There are other brands that do a good job at a decent price. If you use your tools for a living it probably impacts tool purchases also. I do, and I like my Snap-on tools. If ya gotta use 'em all day, you should buy ones that you like. I buy most of my tools on ebay or Craigslist to keep the cost in line.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

BDT/NWMN

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 22, 2012
Messages
3,762
Location
Erskine, Mn
I have SnapOn tools because I like them and they have served me well for 52

years of wrenching, I certainly don't need to justify my purchases to anyone.....

I buy the best tools I can get....and have zero issues


you buy what ever you want.....I couldn't care less

;)

Noel, I surely agree with not needing to justify a tool purchase to anyone else.. Being it is our money; it is our choice on how high we raise the bar of standards.. Snap-On is top of the line in most cases, and that is why other brands are often compared to Snap-On. Snap-On and ProTo are in my inner circle of tool choices, and I have an outer circle of two dozen other brands.. Anything outside of that gives me a cold, numb, pissed off feeling at the sight of them... The money I pissed away on Pittsburg wrenches and Craftsman rp ratchets is money pissed away... I am planning to weld that **** into a humanoid figure and name it "Old Ratchet ***" If I need any help with the welding project; I might have to give you a call: :lol:
 

Lexus

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 16, 2013
Messages
106
Location
Arizona
People who think Snap-on is overpriced haven't used enough different brands of tools to know the difference; nor have they done enough mechanical work to understand the advantages of Snap-on. I wish I could live an extra 100 years just so I could buy more Snap-on.

Dont get me wrong, snap on makes excellent tools but they are NOT the best at everything...

Flankdrive plus wrenches is where they take the lead but the ratchets are not the #1 best out there. Sockets are great but someone else takes the lead their. Air tools, great impacts but the air ratchets are not that great.
 

joel63

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 9, 2012
Messages
1,907
Location
Central FL
I have SnapOn tools because I like them and they have served me well for 52

years of wrenching, I certainly don't need to justify my purchases to anyone.....

I buy the best tools I can get....and have zero issues


you buy what ever you want.....I couldn't care less what you buy, its your money


;)

This works for me. :D
 

franzdom

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 7, 2009
Messages
3,136
Location
NC
I was just wondering why my fellow mechanics all buy snap on and blue point. It Seems like a waste of money to me, because I have had the same set of Gray Canada wrenches for all the time I have been working, and even the chrome is still good on them. My mechanic friends complain about broken tools sometimes, yet I have only broken a few tools in my life. I have always used Gray, old craftsman, belzer, and old husky. The snap on tools that I own, in my opinion, don't exceed the quality of the others. I don't want people attacking me, I just want to know why you think they are better.

How about this: if you don't think they are better you don't belong in this thread? :bounce:
 

lugnut71

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 14, 2013
Messages
1,898
Location
Wyoming
I started buyin snap on twenty five years ago, back then it was that or what the local parts store was selling. Twenty years ago I started as a full time mechanic since then I get $25 per week tool allowance. So it was a no brainer to buy the best, and I have enjoyed using them every day since. Yes, now I buy stuff off internet or pawn shop, but that was non existant 20 yrs ago.
 

Exceller8

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 19, 2012
Messages
2,337
Location
Banning, CA
I haven't read all of the posts, but one thing that isn't being talked about much is the quality of the tool itself. Anyone can make a tool look great but what is the quality of the steel being used? How is the tool heat treated, etc...

As a former knife collector, I know that different steels in knife blades can easily cost 10 to 20X more on knives with a premium quality blade steel vs a low cost blade steel.

It's kind of hard to tell with tools as we don't always know what type of steel is being used or how the tool is heat treated, etc...
 

ATC

Well-known member
Joined
May 12, 2012
Messages
8,257
Location
VA
I haven't read all of the posts, but one thing that isn't being talked about much is the quality of the tool itself. Anyone can make a tool look great but what is the quality of the steel being used? How is the tool heat treated, etc...

As a former knife collector, I know that different steels in knife blades can easily cost 10 to 20X more on knives with a premium quality blade steel vs a low cost blade steel.

It's kind of hard to tell with tools as we don't always know what type of steel is being used or how the tool is heat treated, etc...

So true. There is a fine line between soft and weak....and strong and brittle. Ya gotta find the right balance between them.
 

Exceller8

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 19, 2012
Messages
2,337
Location
Banning, CA
So true. There is a fine line between soft and weak....and strong and brittle. Ya gotta find the right balance between them.

And all of that costs $$$. I see too many people here post that X tool looks just like Y tool. Looks don't really mean anything unless you just want shiny chrome wrenches to look at in your box. :D
 

ATC

Well-known member
Joined
May 12, 2012
Messages
8,257
Location
VA
And all of that costs $$$. I see too many people here post that X tool looks just like Y tool. Looks don't really mean anything unless you just want shiny chrome wrenches to look at in your box. :D

SO's heat treating process doesn't "cost" any more than another brand that heat treats. Sure, they might have spent a lot more to find their special "recipe" for it...but in the end, all tool manufacturers have a furnace and a quenching bath. The amount of time they spend in each doesn't cost the company much.

Now, the alloy of the steel they use could play a part...but unless we know what each company uses...we're all just ******* in the wind with this argument
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Hiball

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 30, 2009
Messages
14,026
Location
Missery
And all of that costs $$$. I see too many people here post that X tool looks just like Y tool. Looks don't really mean anything unless you just want shiny chrome wrenches to look at in your box. :D

Lol.. I knew this wouldn't go over well, you just crushed a lot of hopes and dreams.

Way to go Exceller8
 

franzdom

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 7, 2009
Messages
3,136
Location
NC
Don't say that, now all of em are gonna get butthurt. :eyecrazy:

Crying-Baby-Natural-High-for-Some-Moms.jpg


:D
 

Parrothead

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 27, 2014
Messages
5,346
Location
Earth
Listen, the college thing is all relative.. People go, or don't go, for different reasons. Likewise, some kids amass pretty steep debt in loans while trying to "find themselves" in school.. While expensive, such is life, and no one is really equipped to make these decisions at such a young age.. We can all make cases of people that spent too much on school and wind up not making what WE think they should.. HOWEVER - you will be hard pressed to find many people making $250k a year that DIDNT goto college. Also, what u need to keep in mind for those of us that are middle aged, the people you know with corporate work that have degrees may still be progressing in their careers.. So what they make now may just be a stepping stone, while mechanics will pretty much make they same wage from now until retirement except for inflation wage increases. There was a time my older sister gave me hell that I made as much as she did. I have no degree, but a union job, while she spent years in school and is still paying for it.. Fast forward 10 years and her quarterly bonus are now almost half my annual salary..

Getting back to the point I was trying to make, is snap on has iNts place. I just honestly don't feel it's in the hands of a work for someone else $25/hr mechanic - and that's being generous. Certainly not in the hands of students being lured in with the promise of high paying careers and the "idea" that going into debt to buy as many snap on tools as possible while still in school is a "good idea". many of these guys work for cash with no 401k or benefits, yet they spend $200 on a set of 3/8 extensions cause the $20 set from craftsman is "beneath" them..

If you work off a service truck traveling to remote locations, buy snap on.. If your a mechanic in a pit crew rebuilding the same engine every 2 weeks, and u have real concerns rounding off bolts since you are turning THE SAME BOLTS all the time, buy snap on.. If your working in a corner garage doing oil changes and brakes on 20 year old Hondas, MAYBE gearwrench might be a wiser choice for you. If you are worried that the $15 harbor freight extensions MIGHT break one day - buy 2 sets- they still have a lifetime warranty and you can buy extras and still have spend 2/3 less than a snap on set you might break or loose anyway.. If you are going to swear it's all about making money, then saving money should be an equal concern too..

Finally, you guys DO REALIZE that this whole tool truck thing only came to be because there was no internet to shop on years ago right? These guys don't show up every week out of the kindness of their hearts. They only show up to collect money from all the people that owe weekly payments..

This is the best response to this post...ever:rocker:
 

Ruger_556

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 8, 2013
Messages
4,005
And all of that costs $$$. I see too many people here post that X tool looks just like Y tool. Looks don't really mean anything unless you just want shiny chrome wrenches to look at in your box. :D

Hey now, don't be using reasonable arguments... Someone might get **** hurt :lol:
 

Exceller8

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 19, 2012
Messages
2,337
Location
Banning, CA
Hey now, don't be using reasonable arguments... Someone might get **** hurt :lol:

True! :D

Funny thing is I see both sides. Import tools have their place but that doesn't mean that Snap-On is overpriced. I love the Snap-On tools that I have and I do buy most of them used simply because I can't afford to buy them new.

Snap-On makes an outstanding product. It's up to you to decide if they're worth the $$$ or not.
 

spoon671

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 31, 2014
Messages
403
Location
SFCA
Snap-On makes an outstanding product. It's up to you to decide if they're worth the $$$ or not.

Snap-On sockets, along with other American and Chinese brands (Husky, MasterCraft, Johnnesway, etc.) have a cheaper finishing process, it seems. Plain chrome all of them. :(

I really miss the knurling on the early Snap-On sockets. The knurling, for lack of a better term, is decorative on the newer style, more typical Snap-On socket. Below is a picture of both early, and later model socket by Snap-On.

snapon_12dr_12pt_taper_f_cropped.jpg


TMM14.jpg



This decorative type of knurling is tacky.. is this a quality of an "outstanding" socket?
 
Last edited:

ez-duzit

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 24, 2013
Messages
5,094
Location
Marina del Rey
The old style knurl can do a lot of damage to polished or highly finished parts and soft items like wiring harnesses.
 

spoon671

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 31, 2014
Messages
403
Location
SFCA
The **** are you talking about Spoon

The hash marks (it's not knurling) indicate metric sockets, while the ones without are SAE.


Ahhh, lol I remember now. How embarrassing! Thanks for the reminder. :beer:

Why did Snap-On do away with the knurling? The knurling was functional.
 

spoon671

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 31, 2014
Messages
403
Location
SFCA
The old style knurl can do a lot of damage to polished or highly finished parts and soft items like wiring harnesses.


I see this point, but I don't agree that knurling can be an issue as you say. Was it the positioning of the knurl that caused damage?
 

supersteve

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 2, 2012
Messages
451
Location
Camas, WA
I see this point, but I don't agree that knurling can be an issue as you say. Was it the positioning of the knurl that caused damage?

Stick a knurled socket on the end of an air ratchet, then jam that up against a plastic cowl panel/trim panel/wire harness/whatever you have to to try and get at that semi-hidden bolt and let 'er rip. Yer gonna do some damage.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom