Well.... after stripping the red off I decided it just looked too rough. While these little bullets are obviously highly collectible, they are not by any means particularly rare so I had no issues with not staying original.
I did not have anything laying around here at the shop that really rung my bell for it. But then I noticed a rattle can of fake chrome over in the corner (works great for reflectors like in grinder guards) so I figured what the hell. Its not like this little guy will be tough to paint again. You can dissemble the entire thing and strip all of the paint in about 15 minutes.
Shot a couple of coats on and I actually kinda dig it in a cheesy sort of way. What I think would be awesome (and I might very well try it one day on this or another) would be to really grind, file, and sand the castings glass smooth and have one really chrome plated.
So here it is hanging up and blinged out....

I also pounded the dent out of the rear cap and polished that and the handle and anvil top. I'm quite sure many of you will not like this look. Honestly not yet sure if I do for that matter. Once it dries I'll probably hand brush the top of the lettering and give it a shot of clear.