Thanks. I'm certainly no expert on hafting axes (done 10 or so later model axes), but after hafting this once it looked awful. It was a tight fit but after playing around with it, I eventually removed it. I'll try again at some point, or have somebody with a more skilled hand do it. Normally I'm form over function but I have this hand picked to be my boy's first axe. He's only two so I have some time...at least six months?
Here are pictures of the eye:
It's fairly hard to get good pictures, but the size and steep taper were a bit difficult. I ordered a handle from Handle House and had picked up one previously at a local Ace Hardware for a different project. Both were boy's axe sizes (~28"). The latter was closer in size and shape, so I went with it and you already know how that went. The original handle was 23" long (upper right of linked page):
https://books.google.com/books?id=m_7XltzVxYsC&pg=PA30&lpg=PA30&dq=Vaughan+boys+axe+bsa&source=bl&ots=lYZTIAwjwW&sig=5zYjmZr-66mB2rE2czoTgAnEaEw&hl=en&sa=X&ei=-Rr-UJzhAcar2QX4koGQAg&ved=0CFgQ6AEwBA#v=onepage&q=Vaughan%20boys%20axe%20bsa&f=false
There are very few, if any, options for a ~24" handle without making your own. So I went larger, and that didn't work out. I think I have a little more patience these days and will likely try something else once things slow down.