To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Between 265 & 485 SQ/FT Nick's Two-Car Detached Vdub Garage

Workspaces sized between 265 and 485 squarefeet.
OP
N

nicholam77

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 18, 2016
Messages
2,673
Location
Minneapolis, MN
Nick, cracking the reservoir cap will still let the seven-year-old brake fluid back up into the system and may cause an overflow. That stuff is an excellent paint remover so be careful. As your brake pads have worn over the past seven years, the fluid level in the reservoir had to drop and at some point fluid was added. If your fluid was less than two years old, it probably wouldn't matter but I would err on the side of caution and crack the bleeder screw. To prevent air getting into the caliper I would attach a length of hose to the bleeder and put the end of the hose in a bottle with brake fluid covering the end of the hose. I use a tall skinny olive jar so it isn't a lot of brake fluid. It's actually how I used to bleed the brakes when I was doing it alone.

Thanks for the detailed advice, Bob.

If you're planning on flushing the brake fluid, ya, use the Bosch 5.1 . Rockauto had great pricing on it. I did an exhaustive deep dive on brake fluid a while back and use the Bosch 5.1 on all the cars, regardless of OEM DOT 3, or 4 spec. I think @Bob Heine and I were rabbit holing on this topic at the same time a year back or so..ha.

Thank you for all the info, Dennis. My priority is getting the pads and rotors done on the CX-5, but yes I plan to flush the fluid for both cars this summer.

The CX-5 electronic parking brake has a service mode that winds the brake back. It specifically says not to rotate the piston while compressing the rears for some reason to do with the electronic parking brake. In any case I have a handful of videos to reference for that part.

100% agree with you on lubricating them once a year. I'll make that part of the routine.

If you live anywhere where you have salt on the road, do yourself a favor and get fully coated rotors. I've been running the Raybestos Element3 rotors on both mine and my wife's vehicles and have had great luck with them. It is so nice having no rust on the wheel/hub mounting surfaces causing sticking and no flaky rust falling out of the vents and OD. Also had no warping on any of them, which is more than I can say for many of the more expensive uncoated/partially coated rotors I've bought over the years.

Oh yeah, I live somewhere with salt on the road!!! :ROFLMAO:

I think I'm going to order the Raybestos Element3 coated rotors from Rockauto, and the OEM Mazda pads and hardware from the dealer. I hear you on the benefits of ceramic. Maybe I will try them in the future.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Mr. Roboto

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 11, 2012
Messages
2,161
Location
New Hampshire
Sorry I am just replying now. but thanks for all of the advice on the dimmer switch. Got some option to think about!

Man, what a bummer about the screen. It's so annoying to go through a procedure like that, only to have it not work due to something that is entirely out of your control. I hope the seller is able to send you a new one without too much hassle. I would think that they should cover that return shipping.... not your fault!

Glad to see you doing the brake job, too. Doing your own pads/rotors is often the gateway to taking on more mechanical jobs... at least that's how it went for me! And I would certainly do the rotors as well, based on the vibrating/age/mileage. I am a big proponent of OEM parts on cars I keep mostly factory (i.e. cars other than my Jeep) and brakes are one thing I make an exception for. It's hard to justify the cost for OEM components on a wear item like brakes. For the last few years, I have exclusively been buying the powerstop geomet fully coated rotors with ceramic pads for our cars. They have always performed just as well as the OEM stuff they were replacing.
 
OP
N

nicholam77

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 18, 2016
Messages
2,673
Location
Minneapolis, MN
Man, what a bummer about the screen. It's so annoying to go through a procedure like that, only to have it not work due to something that is entirely out of your control. I hope the seller is able to send you a new one without too much hassle. I would think that they should cover that return shipping.... not your fault!

Yeah, it's been annoying. Has happened to me a few times with international packages, which are always expensive to return, and a struggle dealing with a foreign seller.

After pressuring the seller for a week straight, they finally gave me a refund. I haven't even sent it back yet. I told him what shipping was ($44 USPS), but I think he has to pay a courier pick up fee on his end. He hasn't really agreed to pay that yet. So... need to square that away but at least I got my original payment back.

I just ordered a new one, claims to be new wholesale from a Chinese site. I have two other people on the Golfmk7 forums vouching for it and price is good even though the site is a tad janky. Shipping is FedEx though so I should have it within a week!

Glad to see you doing the brake job, too. Doing your own pads/rotors is often the gateway to taking on more mechanical jobs... at least that's how it went for me! And I would certainly do the rotors as well, based on the vibrating/age/mileage. I am a big proponent of OEM parts on cars I keep mostly factory (i.e. cars other than my Jeep) and brakes are one thing I make an exception for. It's hard to justify the cost for OEM components on a wear item like brakes. For the last few years, I have exclusively been buying the powerstop geomet fully coated rotors with ceramic pads for our cars. They have always performed just as well as the OEM stuff they were replacing.

Yeah, when we bought our cars in 2015 and 2016, I vowed I was going to do all the maintenance on them. And then house happened. And then kid happened. And then covid and another kid happened. I've been on top of oil changes, tires, filters, replacing basic stuff like wiper blades and topping fluids. But I'm feeling a little guilty about not noticing / letting the brakes slide. I'm hoping this will be the start of tackling some more jobs like you said. My GTI has less miles by far (40k vs 113k!!) but I have a few maintenance items to look into on my car, too.

I ended up ordering the OEM Mazda pads and the Raybestos Element3 coated rotors. The Powerstop Geomet was the other option I was considering. Obviously everyone is going to have their preferred parts and what works for them. I'm in full agreement — the OEM parts were expensive. I had to pick up some tools and supplies for this like the piston compressor, brake cleaner, lubricant, anti-seize, etc. Including tools and supplies it came out to about $500. Which is still less than it would be at a shop I think, plus I'll get the experience. But next time I can definitely see going 3rd party on the pads.

I don't know if I'll have a chance to get it done until the weekend after 4th of July, but we'll see.

🍻
 

isonic

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 1, 2018
Messages
213
Location
Ham Lake, MN
I can vouch that brakes are the automotive gateway drug....errr gateway job! I think I did my first brake job when I was 15. Honda accord rear drums!! Second automotive job was a clutch on my '69 Chev truck, so things escalated quickly!

It can pay off having some basic automotive skills. Recently my mother in law was quoted $1K for a rear brake job (crazy high btw). I told her I would replace the pads and look the rotors over. She had no idea I could fix brakes. A few hours of my time saved her a bunch of cash and earned me a free weekend of baby sitting for two kids under 5!!
 
OP
N

nicholam77

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 18, 2016
Messages
2,673
Location
Minneapolis, MN
I can vouch that brakes are the automotive gateway drug....errr gateway job! I think I did my first brake job when I was 15. Honda accord rear drums!! Second automotive job was a clutch on my '69 Chev truck, so things escalated quickly!

Nice! Well sign me up, maybe I can do my GTI clutch in a year or two :ROFLMAO:

It can pay off having some basic automotive skills.

For sure. I've done a few things, but am green compared to a lot of you on here. Before our current cars, I had an Mk4 Jetta, and my wife had a Saab 93 Turbo passed down from her dad. That car had all sorts of problems. On the Jetta I did an engine thermostat, as well as many electrical projects like radios, illuminated shift knob, retrofitting heated seats, etc. On the Saab I managed to do a valve cover gasket, replace the power steering pump as well as purge it of engine oil (was driven by cam shaft and the seal was junk), replace the brake vacuum pump (same situation, camshaft seal leaking), and the HVAC blower motor. Some old pics for fun:

IMG_6419.jpg
IMG_6532.jpg
IMG_6906.jpg
IMG_6913.jpg
IMG_6929.jpg

Recently my mother in law was quoted $1K for a rear brake job (crazy high btw).

🤯

I didn't get a quote for my wife's car but that makes me feel good about doing it. I'm sure it's high around the cities.

A few hours of my time saved her a bunch of cash and earned me a free weekend of baby sitting for two kids under 5!!

That truly is the best prize! Kids are great, but so is having a break sometimes!

🍻
 
OP
N

nicholam77

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 18, 2016
Messages
2,673
Location
Minneapolis, MN
4th of July

Happy 4th everyone. I've been busy and have lots to catch up on.

Before the actual 4th we did a kiddie bike / scooter parade at the neighborhood park, and the kids got to go in the fire engine.

IMG_1773.jpg

Then for the weekend we headed to the in-laws cabin. I was worried about taking my wife's car, because of the brakes, and I popped the hood to test the brake fluid with the little tester I got because of @Bob Heine , and not only was the fluid a *bit* low, but I noticed the negative battery terminal was extremely corroded.

IMG-1827.jpg

The battery is only a year old, so something's up.

So we road-tripped in the GTI. :cool:

Somewhat surprisingly, it hauled everything we needed.

IMG_1854.jpg
IMG_1857.jpg

At the cabin it was a perfect-weather weekend, with lots of boating and time in the sun.

IMG_1860.jpg
IMG_1902.jpg
IMG_1893.jpg

Just before we left for the cabin, our giant silver maple dropped a branch in the middle of the night.

IMG_1846.jpg

It didn't do any real damage, but was resting on a neighbor's phone line, and barely brushing their power line.

IMG_1850.jpg
IMG_1853.jpg

We called about 15 companies to come look at it but most were 3-4 weeks out. Only one was able to come Friday, and quoted $2200. 🤯

While we were gone, our neighbor found a guy who would do it for $800 so we split it. I haven't had to deal with this before, seems like a lot still, but I'm not too surprised it seems like everything is a $1000 these days.

IMG_1935.jpg

He didn't haul it away, so I'm going to split the stumps for firewood when I have time.

On the actual 4th, we were back in Minneapolis and tried to go to a parade in the morning. But right as it was about to start, a torrential downpour started and they cancelled. It was the most rain we've had in a long time. Good for the plants, a bit of a bummer for the celebration.

IMG_1992.jpg
IMG_2001.jpg

I've been accumulating parts for the Mazda brake job, and ending up getting the fronts done on Monday night! But I'm going to put more detail into a separate post for that.

IMG_1838.jpg
IMG_1988.jpg

Beyond that, we've still had intermittent poor air quality from the Canada wildfires (You can barely make out the city skyline below).

IMG_1834.jpg

And I've been tackling various house projects like some gutter work.

Hope everyone in the U.S. had a relaxing and fun holiday!

🍻
 
Last edited:

kaymccampbell

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 27, 2015
Messages
29,588
Location
Upstate New York
4th of July

Happy 4th everyone. I've been busy and have lots to catch up on.

Before the actual 4th we did a kiddie bike / scooter parade at the neighborhood park, and the kids got to go in the fire engine.

IMG_1773.jpg

Then for the weekend we headed to the in-laws cabin. I was worried about taking my wife's car, because of the brakes, and I popped the hood to test the brake fluid with the little tester I got because of @Bob Heine , and not only was the fluid a *bit* low, but I noticed the negative battery terminal was extremely corroded.

IMG-1827.jpg

The battery is only a year old, so something's up.

So we road-tripped in the GTI. :cool:

Somewhat surprisingly, it hauled everything we needed.

IMG_1854.jpg
IMG_1857.jpg

At the cabin it was a perfect-weather weekend, with lots of boating and time in the sun.

IMG_1860.jpg
IMG_1902.jpg
IMG_1893.jpg

Just before we left for the cabin, our giant silver maple dropped a branch in the middle of the night.

IMG_1846.jpg

It didn't do any real damage, but was resting on a neighbor's phone line, and barely brushing their power line.

IMG_1850.jpg
IMG_1853.jpg

We called about 15 companies to come look at it but most were 3-4 weeks out. Only one was able to come Friday, and quoted $2200. 🤯

While we were gone, our neighbor found a guy who would do it for $800 so we split it. I haven't had to deal with this before, seems like a lot still, but I'm not too surprised it seems like everything is a $1000 these days.

IMG_1935.jpg

He didn't haul it away, so I'm going to split the stumps for firewood when I have time.

On the actual 4th, we were back in Minneapolis and tried to go to a parade in the morning. But right as it was about to start, a torrential downpour started and they cancelled. It was the most rain we've had in a long time. Good for the plants, a bit of a bummer for the celebration.

IMG_1992.jpg
IMG_2001.jpg

I've been accumulating parts for the Mazda brake job, and ending up getting the fronts done on Monday night! But I'm going to put more detail into a separate post for that.

IMG_1838.jpg
IMG_1988.jpg

Beyond that, we've still had intermittent poor air quality from the Canada wildfires (You can barely make out the city skyline below).

IMG_1834.jpg

And I've been tackling various house projects like some gutter work.

Hope everyone in the U.S. had a relaxing and fun holiday!

🍻
$800 for a treemergency is a gift.
 
OP
N

nicholam77

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 18, 2016
Messages
2,673
Location
Minneapolis, MN
CX-5 Front Brakes

Spoiler alert, everything went smoothly on this. I watched about 5 YouTube videos and read countless mazda247.org forum posts ahead of time. I am going to present it in detail anyways, because there were a few moments I wasn't sure if I was doing the "right" thing. Please feel free to chime in with any suggestions or comments.

Lifting the car was easier than mine, because I could get a jack under the front crossmember / subframe and place two stands at once.

IMG-1937.jpg

Also, unlike my car, I've never taken the wheels off the Mazda. I've done 80% of the oil changes, but tire rotations etc have been at a shop. Definitely some corrosion and grime.

IMG-1939.jpg

Some of the caliper / caliper bracket bolts needed a little penetrating oil, but then all came off easily.

IMG-1941.jpg

The rotors on the other hand, needed a lot of penetrating oil and a good pounding. I feel like there's a Michael Scott GIF that could be inserted here. 😬

IMG-1955.jpg
IMG-1958.jpg
IMG-1957.jpg

I guess I have no way to measure flatness, but I thought the part of the rotor that the pads contact actually looked in pretty decent shape.

I took some pictures of the crusty caliper bracket for reference later.

IMG-1942.jpg

The hardware was pretty crusty.

IMG-1946.jpg

Slide pins and dust boots in good shape, although not much lubricant left.

IMG-1947.jpg

The caliper bracket itself had rust and grime, and no matter how much Brakleen and wire brushing I did, it didn't improve the appearance much.

And now for the embarrassing part. And I'm not exactly surprised. But there was zero friction material left on the old pads. Guess they had a good run!

IMG-1944-split.jpg

The old pads (and the new) came with a bunch of shims. I was kind of confused by this, as most aftermarket kits I've seen in videos don't seem to use them. But these had two shims per pad, that go on top of each other, and one is slotted and one is solid. They came with some very poor paper instructions and some little baggies of some sort of paste (anti-seize perhaps?), but I couldn't work out what to do from the diagrams so I just put them on the same way the old ones were, and applied some of my own Permatex copper anti-seize in between the "layers".

I'm not sure if the anti-seize was a good idea, bad idea, doesn't matter?? Chime in!

IMG-1949.jpg
IMG-1950.jpg
IMG-1951.jpg

Something I saw in a video was to put CRC "Disc Brake Quiet" on the outside of the pads, and on the back of the hardware (where it contacts the caliper bracket). And in some videos they didn't do this. I figured it couldn't hurt.


IMG-1953.jpg
IMG-1952.jpg

Btw, did I mention it was like 100° F in my garage while doing this? Drenched in sweat.

I got the slide pins and dust boots cleaned up, and put a liberal amount of Permatix ceramic extreme silicone brake parts lubricant.

IMG-1962.jpg
IMG-1973.jpg

Too much? I didn't want to skimp but was kind of guessing here.

And some on the hardware and pad ears.

IMG-1974.jpg
IMG-1975.jpg

And holy cow that Permatex stuff is slippery. All assembled.

IMG-1976.jpg

Looks like a 2 yr old's finger painting. :ROFLMAO:

To push back the caliper, I cracked the reservoir cap. I know this was against the wise @Bob Heine 's advice, but I didn't gather the appropriate equipment to crack the bleeder screw. Nothing spilled over the top and I didn't even turkey baster any out. I think the bigger risk is pushing the old fluid back through the ABS system, but in every video and post I watched, everyone just cracked the reservoir cap, so hopefully no damage done. Getting the fluid flush done is on my shortlist, for both cars.

To compress the piston, I used the old pad as a "block" to apply even pressure and not go too far, although I think somehow I did because the seal buckled a little. Hopefully fine.

IMG-1969.jpg
IMG-1970.jpg

On the rotor side, I cleaned the new one with brake parts cleaner, and applied Permatex copper anti-seize to the inside where it contacts the hub. Again, looking for a yes or no on this. I've always put anti-seize on my wheel spacers on the GTI so they don't weld to the wheel / hub and it's worked for me. I thought if I ever have to do rotors again on this vehicle *maybe* it will make them easier to get off.

IMG-1968.jpg

Old vs. new fully-coated Raybestos Element3:

IMG-1967.jpg

I noticed there was rust on the control arms and suspension bits, so while I had it apart I sprayed it down with FluidFilm. I know it's not @Denwood favorite Noxudol product but it's all I had on hand.

IMG-1963.jpg

To hold the rotor in place while I reattached the caliper, I used some cherry and maple offcuts. I knew I was saving these for a reason!

IMG-1971.jpg

My trusty Tekton torque wrench in action. I was able to find torque specs for all the bolts.

IMG-1982.jpg

And what do you know, 3 hours later, I'm done!

IMG-1984.jpg
IMG-1985.jpg

... with one side!! Arrrrgh it's 9:30 pm already!

Fortunately, I felt like I knew what I was doing at this point, and it only took about another hour to bang out the other side (most parts already removed), and get the wheels back on.

I did a quick drive around the block around 11 pm. No shaking, no squeaks, no noises whatsoever. Pedal felt really good.

I was wiped out and wanted to crash into bed, but unfortunately I was very dirty and had to take a night shower. Ended up getting to bed around 1 am.

I didn't find this job hard by any means, but it still felt rewarding, and a change of pace for something that has mostly evolved into "woodworking garage".

🍻
 

Denwood

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 22, 2014
Messages
4,192
Location
Thunder Bay, Ontario, Canada
That’s a very thorough job:) Torquing to spec is smart and checking twice even better. I use a bit of anti seize on the bolts and adjust for wet torque. I’ve had one experience with a caliper that came off and ended up in the wheel rim likely as I was in a rush and forgot to check twice..brake fluid leaked out as the piston also popped out…not a good situation.

A few points:

1. That “spare” threaded hole in the disc is to run a bolt in to pop them off :)

2. You can cut back lube like 80%. Just a light coat and only on contact points…like where the caliper actually contacts the pads.

3. No need to hold the rotor in place. Usually there is a screw in place to hold the rotor in play, but the wheel bolts are what keep it stable and the pads will align themselves.

4. On your next service, it will go a lot more quickly as you’ll just pull the pads and pins with a quick clean and lube on contact points.

4. Give pads and disc surface a quick hit with brake cleaner and compressed air as your last step before assembly.

Torquing the wheels in a star pattern and to correct torque should prevent warping, but a panic stop from highway speeds (and no cool down) can warp them again.
 
Last edited:
OP
N

nicholam77

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 18, 2016
Messages
2,673
Location
Minneapolis, MN
2. You can cut back lube like 80%. Just a light coat and only on contact points…like where the caliper actually contacts the pads.

:ROFLMAO:

Thanks Dennis, that's exactly the type of feedback I was looking for.

I figured I used way too much lubricant, but it is details like that that aren't always clearly answered in internet tutorials, whether they be videos or print, which is why I wanted to ask here. I think in my head, I noticed how dry everything was, and overcompensated. Feeling the need to put more to make it last longer. I'll do less next time, at the "servicing".

I was aware of the hole to help get the rotors off, but I didn't have the appropriate bolt on hand (an M8 x 1.25, at least 30mm length I believe). But that was my plan B if the mallet didn't work. I would say I only pounded "medium hard" and rotated the rotor as I went. Didn't want to break anything. Despite needing the mallet, they didn't give me that much trouble and I had them both free within about a minute.

The Mazda uses wheel studs and lug nuts, so it was helpful to have the rotor pinned in place with the lug nuts for reassembly (the blocks of wood were just a spacer since the wheel was missing). Otherwise the rotor would tilt and wobble and make fitting the caliper bracket back on more fiddly. I can see this being different on my car, for example, which uses wheel bolts instead.

Wheels were torqued to spec in a star pattern. 😁

Torquing to spec is smart and checking twice even better. [...] I’ve had one experience with a caliper that came off and ended up in the wheel rim likely as I was in a rush and forgot to check twice..brake fluid leaked out as the piston also popped out…not a good situation.

Yikes! That's scary. I always check twice. The torque spec on the caliper bolts was pretty low. About 20 ft/lb for the bracket bolts and about 48 ft/lb for the caliper. Upon checking, the bracket bolts turned another 1/4 turn or so. I just take that as extra insurance.



Side question for anyone. What to do with the old rotors? Do auto parts stores recycle those (Napa, Advance Auto, etc)?
 

Denwood

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 22, 2014
Messages
4,192
Location
Thunder Bay, Ontario, Canada
Repair shops will have a scrap metal bin and should take your parts as they'll get $$ for them :cool:

On the lube side, you definitely don't want any ending up on the rotor surface. A very light coat is all you need, and only at contact points. If you do a quick service each year and clean up the contact points again, you'll find that everything comes apart nicely. For service, you only need to pop the slide pins..caliper bolts stay in place.

Slide pin torque is usually low, so that sounds about right.

As luck would have it my daughter's car is seeing some pedal judder on higher speed (highway stops) so I literally just picked up a new set of e-coated rotors and Bosch pads for it. Evening job for tonight.
 

bj383ss

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 29, 2011
Messages
3,166
Location
TX
Looks like you nailed it Nick. As Dennis said way too much lube. You only need it on contact points. All opinions of course. But all the Youtube mechanics I watch say the same. Heck until the last pad slap on my truck I had never lubed the pins before. But I don't live in the rust belt either.

I honestly don't even use torque specs. I just do it by feel. As far as the wheels go I torque them with the 4 way I keep in each car. My grandpa taught me that trick. So you are able to get them off on the side of the road with the same tool. Most of the bolts are washer head and apply way more force than you would think they would. I have never had anything come loose so far. :ROFLMAO:

Congratulations on separating yourself from the majority of people who spend 1,000's of dollars to have their brakes fixed.

Bret
 

isonic

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 1, 2018
Messages
213
Location
Ham Lake, MN
1. That “spare” threaded hole in the disc is to run a bolt in to pop them off :)

3. No need to hold the rotor in place. Usually there is a screw in place to hold the rotor in play, but the wheel bolts are what keep it stable and the pads will align themselves.
Nice job! On to the rears next?

Also I never knew that spare hole in the rotor could be used for #1. I always thought it was for cars that also had a whole in the hub so the small little retaining screw could be used as described in #3.
 
OP
N

nicholam77

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 18, 2016
Messages
2,673
Location
Minneapolis, MN
Looks like you nailed it Nick. As Dennis said way too much lube. You only need it on contact points. All opinions of course. But all the Youtube mechanics I watch say the same. Heck until the last pad slap on my truck I had never lubed the pins before. But I don't live in the rust belt either.

I honestly don't even use torque specs. I just do it by feel. As far as the wheels go I torque them with the 4 way I keep in each car. My grandpa taught me that trick. So you are able to get them off on the side of the road with the same tool. Most of the bolts are washer head and apply way more force than you would think they would. I have never had anything come loose so far. :ROFLMAO:

Congratulations on separating yourself from the majority of people who spend 1,000's of dollars to have their brakes fixed.

Thanks Bret! Yes, copy that on the lube.

Obviously you know what you're doing, but I'm too uncomfortable "going by feel" when it comes to things like wheels and brakes. Don't want those to come loose. Also, I was a victim of overtightened lug bolts once. Got a flat tire in my Mk4 in northern Minnesota (middle of nowhere) over 4th of July one year. I could not get the wheel off with the lug wrench in the trunk. Fortunately it was somewhat close to a small town and someone with a truck stopped to help and had a piece of pipe for leverage, but it was on there good. From then on I've been scared of over-tightening wheels. That incident was pre-kids, but now I take a breaker bar with me on road trips.

I was quoted for the rear brakes on the Mazda a year ago (while in for a tire repair). I looked at my files and it was $530. So I'd imagine you are bang on that a full front and rear job would run me north of $1k at a shop. My full cost for the DIY job was just under $500, but that included the more expensive OEM pads and separate hardware, as well as the handful of small tools and consumables. In the future if I went full 3rd party I bet I could get it around $300-$350. That's a lot of $$ to save!

Nice job! On to the rears next?

Also I never knew that spare hole in the rotor could be used for #1. I always thought it was for cars that also had a whole in the hub so the small little retaining screw could be used as described in #3.

Yes, I actually completed them this past weekend. So I still put an insane amount of lubricant on the pins :ROFLMAO:

I'll post a much shorter write up for that.

Everything I came across for this car suggested that little hole was to assist getting the rotors to separate from the hub if they were rusty.
 
OP
N

nicholam77

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 18, 2016
Messages
2,673
Location
Minneapolis, MN
Mazda CX-5 Rear Brakes

Back in the "shop" for round two.

IMG-2101.jpg
IMG-2085.jpg
IMG-2067.jpg

I actually got this done last weekend, so take a step into the Garage Journal Time Machine. Same drill as the fronts, the only unique thing was the electronic parking brake.

IMG-2069.jpg

Before removing the caliper, I needed to put the EPB in "maintenance mode". Fortunately Mazda implemented a button sequence for those without the appropriate OBDII tool. Ignition on, then while holding accelerator pedal all the way down, simultaneously pull up on parking brake switch and rapidly press ignition button 3x.

IMG-2072.jpg
IMG-2071.jpg

This backs off the parking brake motors. Fortunately I read a lot of forum posts on the exact sequence, because I guess if you put it in maintenance mode after removing the caliper, the motor advances instead of retracts, and screws everything up by rotating the piston. Would be an easy mistake to make.

There was less room for a ratchet on one of the caliper bracket bolts, so I tried this trick I saw for linking two wrenches together.

IMG-2077.jpg
IMG-2074.jpg

It did not work and my wrenches were flexing a little, but I was able to get it with a universal and short extension.

Same situation as the fronts, crusty AF and no friction material left.

IMG-2079.jpg

Again, the instructions that came with the OEM pads and hardware were mediocre at best. Half-Kanji half-English-that-didn't-quite-make-sense. Illustrated diagrams at weird angles and too small to decipher. The main question was the hardware came with some little peel and stick tape squares that looked like electrical tape. But I couldn't tell from the diagram if they wanted me to stick it on the front or back of the hardware.

IMG-2080.jpg
IMG-2081.jpg

In my research I came across a technical service bulletin for squeaky rear brakes, so maybe this was some sort of "fix" they came up with?

I decided to just ignore the tape, put the CRC Disc Brake Quiet on the back where the hardware contacts the bracket, and just do the lubricant on the part the pads touch.

Compressing the pistons was just like the fronts, with one important note from the service manual: DO NOT TURN THE PISTON while compressing! Or it could damage internal caliper components related to the parking brake.

IMG-2089.jpg

It pushed mostly straight back. The piston can be turned, but not while it's being compressed. In fact the notches need to be aligned in a north-south orientation because the piston indexes a tab on the inner pad.

IMG-2099.jpg

Mine seemed close enough, and I didn't have a tool to rotate it, so I left it be. It seemed to link up fine, although it's about impossible to get a visual of the tab / indent connection when assembled.

Yeah, I went nuts with lube again. Because this happened before everyone's feedback here.

IMG-2084.jpg

With the fronts I had assembled the pads in the bracket, and then mounted the whole thing on the car. The hardware for the rears was more complicated, and I could not for the life of me get the pads to stay, so I added them once the bracket was screwed to the car. Much easier that way.

IMG-2097.jpg

Yeah I know, too much Permatex (orange stuff), but in case anyone is confused... the red stuff is not lube. That would be the CRC Disc Brake Quiet. And is supposed to go on the outside of the pads. At least that's the impression I was given. It's probably not necessary, but I will say... not a single noise from them so far!

Taking it out of "maintenance mode" is the reverse button sequence, but another important tip — must pump the brakes first to get the pad pin engaged with the piston. Otherwise the parking brake motors will spin the piston and screw up the alignment / not connect with the pad. I had no issues.

And that concludes the brake job!

Like I mentioned last time, I'd probably consider 3rd party ceramic or hybrid pads for the next one, but I have to say the OEM pads feel excellent. No calipers have popped off on the highway. Wife is happy.

🍻
 
Last edited:
OP
N

nicholam77

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 18, 2016
Messages
2,673
Location
Minneapolis, MN
I Hate Electrical Projects / Smart Home Frustrations

Did anyone else go nuts on Prime Day??

IMG-2194.jpg

This left me with some installs to do. But first, here's a pic of my son shoving a donut in his face since he turned two on Saturday!

IMG-2148.jpg

Anyways, I really like that TP-Link Kasa Motion Dimmer switch I got for my main floor bathroom, and I thought I'd add one to our upstairs bathroom (ensuite). Currently it has Phillips HUE bulbs that are always on (wire nutted the line and load together) and 3M taped a HUE battery powered dimmer switch remote over the switch box.

Before ordering the Kasa dimmer, I had removed the HUE dimmer plate to check for a neutral wire, since Kasa (and most smart switches) require it. I saw a few white wires in there and assumed I was good. Well that was not the case.

I am not hopeful, but wondering if anyone on here who understands electrical better than me can help decipher if I have a shot or not:

IMG-2175.jpg

In the picture, the black and white wires "A" and "B" come from the same location, and are what I had wire nutted together where the original mechanical switch used to be. Black is the hot, white goes to power the light when switched on. So no neutral there.

Then there is a second set of wires, black, white, and bare copper, coming up from the bottom. Oddly the white one reads 120v hot, and the black does not.

With a multimeter set to AC Volts at the highest setting, I tested the ground wire "C" by connecting the hots one at a time to it, and it read close to 120v.

With the multimeter, connecting "A" to "C" read close to 0 Volts, which makes sense.

Connecting "D" and "E" read something like ~66 Volts. I have no idea what that means. I have no idea why those bottom wires "D" and "E" are in the box, and why the white one is the hot one. But the ground that is with them seems viable.

So I'm pretty sure I have no options for neutral, but wanted to check.



Then I got a regular Kasa WiFi switch for my main floor bathroom exhaust fan. Same thing, took the cover plate off, peaked in with a flash light, saw a white wire and called it good. Well, turns out the wires (black, white, bare copper) are a single drop, and the black and white are the line / load for the fan. So there is no neutral.

Now I don't know what I want to do. This Kasa switch was only $11 on sale. No-neutral smart switches exist, but they are typically dimmer switches which isn't ideal for a fan, and they generally are in the $40-$60 range.

I've considered a smart relay behind the mechanical switch, but I think the lack of an up-down / on-off state would drive my OCD nuts.

If @Denwood or anyone else has any ideas for these no-neutral situations, I'm all ears!



Lastly, and this one's my fault, I ordered a couple of Kasa multicolor light strips with the intention to use them for under cabinet lighting in the kitchen. Maybe I'd throw on a fun color once in a blue moon, but my main use case would be a warm white to match other 2700k lighting.

I quickly realized this wasn't going to happen since the light strips are RGB only and don't have a dedicated cool or warm white diode. They can approximate white, but it's not up to my standards. I think I'll be sending them back.



Then I got 4x Zigbee smart plugs from Third Reality, a well-reviewed brand. I got them all to pair to Hubitat, but they are a bit slow to react sometimes, and not 100% reliable. I've always felt my Zigbee devices aren't as reliable on Hubitat. That might be because my Hubitat hub is right near one of my router access points, and both WiFi and Zigbee use the 2.4 GhZ band, so there could be some interference going on.

I'm left wondering if...

a ) the Zigbee plugs I bought are just not that great
b ) I should move my Hubitat hub to the kitchen, which would require running a cat6 drop from the attic which is a headache
c ) I should get a Zigbee stick for my Home Assistant server and move my Zigbee devices over to that, hoping for a more powerful radio and better signal

I imagine very few of you care about these details, but I thought I would illustrate that even someone like me, who is pretty well-versed in this stuff, struggles with the hobbyist smart home from time-to-time. It's just the reality of it!
 

Chrisb62

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 30, 2019
Messages
1,093
Location
southwest fl
...........I am not an electrician ..........

If I understand correctly... the mechanical switch that was there previously only ran the light...
if so the "A" wire and "E" normally are attached to the opposite ends of the switch
"B" and "D" wires are normally wire nutted together (neutral wires)

Separate "A" and "B" and do a continuity "OHM" check between "B" and "D"
If there is indeed continuity (meter moves) that means that the above statements are true.


...........I am not an electrician ..........


Hopefully this is the information you were looking for.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
OP
N

nicholam77

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 18, 2016
Messages
2,673
Location
Minneapolis, MN
If I understand correctly... the mechanical switch that was there previously only ran the light...

That is correct.

if so the "A" wire and "E" normally are attached to the opposite ends of the switch
"B" and "D" wires are normally wire nutted together (neutral wires)

Normally that's what I would expect, yes. That is not the case, though. "A" + "B" are what would be attached to the switch (when they are connected, the light gets power).

It must be that the power source goes to the fixture first and then loops down to the switch.

The second set of wires "C", "D", "E", are part of the same Romex bundle and I have no idea what they control. The white is the power for some reason. Probably a mystery box buried in the wall somewhere.

I'll try your continuity test, but I'm pretty sure it's not set up the way you'd expect.

But I appreciate you chiming in!
 
OP
N

nicholam77

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 18, 2016
Messages
2,673
Location
Minneapolis, MN
More smart home musings.

I returned the Kasa light strips and the motion dimmer switch.

I kept the Zigbee smart plugs, although I'm having some reliability issues. I probably should have sent those back, too — I'm at a point in my smart home journey were I don't really entertain stuff that doesn't work well.



Yesterday I finally got another big integration accomplished for Home Assistant — Google Nest.

I'm sure most people have heard of Nest Thermostats. I have one of the original learning thermostats, and one of the original hardwired video doorbells, before they were bought by Google.

Even before the Google acquisition, they really didn't work with much else. Someone hacked together an unofficial integration for SmartThings that used the "Works With Nest" API, but that got deprecated eventually, and the video doorbell was never supported. So I pretty much used my Nest stuff in a sandbox with the Nest app.

Fast forward a bunch of years, and Google comes out with a new API. And now Home Assistant has an integration that leverages it, but it's a royal PITA to set up.

I won't get into details, but after a lot of troubleshooting and forum posts and searches, I finally got it working.

The thermostat has all HVAC modes exposed to Home Assistant, as well as it's "ECO" mode which is Nest-specific. And of course you can target heating and cooling set points.

The doorbell... and this is pretty sweet... has the following triggers exposed:

- Doorbell pressed
- Motion detected
- Person detected
- Sound detected

So I can use any of those "events", and tie it to a different action. It can also access the image previews for those events, as well as the live camera stream.

Unfortunately "Package detected" is missing for some reason.

But picture automations like... when doorbell is pressed, a text-to-speech announcement plays on all Sonos speakers, and casts a live stream of the camera to any TVs that are currently on. Or when a person is detected after 8pm, turn on 'X' lights. Or if a sound is detected at night, send a push notification to our phones. Some very cool possibilities.

So far I set up a very simple one for the thermostat.

Code:
if
    basement TV turns on
then
    set Nest to ECO mode
    
    
if
    basement TV turns off
then
    set Nest to Cool mode and target 73°F


Our basement is always cold in the summer, and I have to shut off the AC every time when we're down there. Now it happens automagically. 😁
 
OP
N

nicholam77

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 18, 2016
Messages
2,673
Location
Minneapolis, MN
Checking in. Since the brake job I haven't gotten much done. And the list of things that needs to get done is growing by the day it feels like.

@Chrisb62 I did not figure out the wiring. I already sent the switch back, though, so it's out of sight out of mind at this point.

A small update — circling back to the infotainment screen upgrade on my GTI, I ordered, received, and installed a replacement screen. It was wholesale from the Chinese market (still authentic VW), and it looks great. I was concerned spending a couple hundred bucks on this wouldn't be worth it, but it really changed the feel of the interior for me.

IMG-2204.jpg

After negotiating back and forth with the eBay seller of the broken screen I received the first time, they gave me a full refund. We had talked about shipping it back, but he kind of dropped the ball (I think it was going to be too expensive to cover), so I still have it sitting around.



Other than that, I've just been enjoying family time and summer with the kids.

Since this is Garage Journal and safe to assume most on here like machinery, here are some pics from an air show I took the kids to last weekend with my brother-in-law.

I don't have any military affiliations or acquaintances (other than both of my grandpa's served in WWII), and I'm not knowledgable about planes whatsoever, but I find these old war planes to be really intriguing and beautiful.

IMG-2259.jpg
IMG-2298.jpg
IMG-2268.jpg
IMG-2292.jpg
IMG-2309.jpg

Most of them were flown during the show.

There was also some newer stuff, like a Blackhawk helicopter, a C47 (I think?) cargo plane, and more.

IMG-2302.jpgIMG-2274.jpg
IMG-2238.jpgIMG-2242.jpg
IMG-2235.jpg



My list of urgent/maintenance projects is growing

— fix leaky hose bib (again)
— wasp nest under shed gable
— brake fluid flush Mazda
— brake fluid flush GTI
— new battery for Mazda
— fix chipped paint / rust on GTI hatch seam
— install shock absorbers GTI
— fix rotted and peeling pain boards on garage trim, replace human door and threshold
— clean out gutters
— install pop-emitter in garden for patio drain
— clean AC

And I have many, many more things that aren't as critical but that I've been meaning to get to.

I'm also feeling a bit disappointed that I haven't done any woodworking this summer. But I'm out of town this weekend, and then starting a huge project at work that will take me through August. So... summer is slipping away fast!

🍻
 

bdbecker

ALLIANCE MEMBER
Joined
Nov 18, 2015
Messages
5,577
Location
Iowa
Might want to add 'snow shovel tune up' to your project list... September will be here soon! Kidding of course. Although an October blizzard is a real possibility.

I feel you on summer speeding by. Wife mentioned she wanted to get school shopping done last weekend. I almost said "we've got time..." but then realized school starts in less than a month. At least I can look forward to not sweating in the shop soon.
 

fourmotioneer

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 19, 2015
Messages
224
Location
Ann Arbor, MI
CX-5 Front Brakes

Spoiler alert, everything went smoothly on this.

And what do you know, 3 hours later, I'm done!

... with one side!! Arrrrgh it's 9:30 pm already!

Fortunately, I felt like I knew what I was doing at this point, and it only took about another hour to bang out the other side (most parts already removed), and get the wheels back on.

I did a quick drive around the block around 11 pm. No shaking, no squeaks, no noises whatsoever. Pedal felt really good.

I was wiped out and wanted to crash into bed, but unfortunately I was very dirty and had to take a night shower. Ended up getting to bed around 1 am.

I didn't find this job hard by any means, but it still felt rewarding, and a change of pace for something that has mostly evolved into "woodworking garage".

🍻

Opening line is a delicious and well-earned humble brag. My impression is that you prepared for the worst and made out ok.

On the idea of the job not being hard but still feeling rewarding: I think there's a Venn diagram of consisting of 1) finite (takes only 3-4 hours) 2) useful and 3) interesting that applies to an evening project for a guy with a young family. I like to get all three if I can, but a good family car job like brakes or an oil change ticks the finite and useful boxes, and that's worth something. Oddly, a routine job that blows out of proportion can move into the useful-interesting overlap if it takes some dedicated problem solving, if you have a positive outlook on things.

And finally: that dreaded night shower. Really best before you even get back in the vehicle. That way, you avoid trashing the seats AND you have to turn in for the night no matter how the job went.

Nice work!
 
OP
N

nicholam77

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 18, 2016
Messages
2,673
Location
Minneapolis, MN
Might want to add 'snow shovel tune up' to your project list... September will be here soon! Kidding of course.

I mean... you're not wrong!

On the idea of the job not being hard but still feeling rewarding: I think there's a Venn diagram of consisting of 1) finite (takes only 3-4 hours) 2) useful and 3) interesting that applies to an evening project for a guy with a young family. I like to get all three if I can, but a good family car job like brakes or an oil change ticks the finite and useful boxes, and that's worth something. Oddly, a routine job that blows out of proportion can move into the useful-interesting overlap if it takes some dedicated problem solving, if you have a positive outlook on things.

Thanks for the kind words. I like your perspective with the Venn diagram. Like you alluded to, since I don't do car work all the time I did plenty of research and preparing. Which did serve me well, but if you count that towards the time it took, it was actually pretty time intensive. 3-4 hours per end, plus many more hours watching YouTube videos, reading forum posts, comparing parts, etc.

I think overall I have a positive outlook on projects, and life, but I'm at a stage where I really prefer if things don't blow out of proportion.

Those Warbirds though!!!

P51, P47, and my personal favorite, the F4U.

Thanks for the model names. They were awesome!
 
OP
N

nicholam77

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 18, 2016
Messages
2,673
Location
Minneapolis, MN
Mazda CX-5 Battery

This is turning into the summer of Nick's Automotive Tasks.

I still have the brake fluid flush in both cars, my shocks for the GTI have been sitting in my basement for 3 months, and the Mazda has some additional issues. I'd been noticing a slight clunk or pop sound over small bumps and low speeds. Fairly minor. Probably for a month or two. Put precedence on the brakes, but now that those are taken care of it's been getting worse. Just in the past week there is a "groaning" when centering the steering from right to left at low speeds. Funny enough it seems like the pops/clunks are coming from the passenger front side, and the groan/squeak is coming from the driver front side. I can't pin point that for sure but that's my hunch.

So... I'm sure it's some suspension or steering component, bushing, mount, who knows. I have it scheduled to go into the shop Saturday morning for a diagnoses, and depending on the quote we'll see where to go from there. If it's super expensive and depending on what the problem(s) are I may look at DIY, but I'm really hoping it can be taken care of by professionals. I'm swamped and don't have the energy for another bigger car project.

IMG-2372.jpg

For today, I'm checking an easy one off the list. When doing the brakes I noticed the battery was super corroded on the negative terminal. I vaguely remember tipping/spilling the battery when installing it. It's only a year old. I'm wondering if maybe some battery acid was on the surface and didn't get fully cleaned. I'm hoping it's that and not a larger issue.

Got a new battery at Costco and went to town.

IMG-2366.jpg

The positive terminal was mostly ok, but what wasn't ok, was the metal bracket that holds the battery down:

IMG-2369.jpg
IMG-2370.jpg

My wife has had a trusted shop do her last two oil changes because I've been too busy. I'm sure this has been this way for awhile and I'm kind of annoyed that the service techs wouldn't mentioned that her battery is corroded AF. The fact that the underside of the bracket was all corroded is what makes me think there was a leak situation.

I did my best to clean things up with baking soda, water, and white vinegar.

IMG-2373.jpg
IMG-2382.jpg
IMG-2377.jpg

The solution took the coating off the negative terminal (I think it was silver-ish before but was hard to tell). Hope that's fine.

Because the bracket was down to bare metal I wanted to paint it, so I ran to the hardware store and got some Rustoleum. And some CRC Battery Terminal Protector. And some wine. 😁

IMG-2375.jpg

I didn't do primer or anything, just a couple coats of this:

IMG-2379.jpg

IMG-2393.jpg

And gave the terminals a healthy spray of the CRC Terminal Protector.

IMG-2383.jpg
IMG-2395.jpg

And we're done. Believe it or not with all the cleaning and scrubbing and trip to the store, this turned into a 3+ job, my whole Sunday afternoon.

But it does feel good to check something off the list.



After that I took some time to clean the workbench, which had still been a disaster since the brake job. No before pics, but I also sorted through my Gladiator cabinets and threw a bunch of stuff away, wiped them down, and reorganized.

IMG-2388.jpg
IMG-2405.jpg
IMG-2407.jpg

I have some other small-ish projects to update later.

🍻
 

bdbecker

ALLIANCE MEMBER
Joined
Nov 18, 2015
Messages
5,577
Location
Iowa
Lol! I should clarify the wine store was next to the hardware store :ROFLMAO:

Eh, close enough...

The Ace Hardware in Vermillion, SD (where I lived for ~5 years) is right next to the liquor store as well. They even share a sign...


Even better, the grocery store was connected to the hardware store. Steak, whisky, and chainsaws all in one convenient location. 'Merica!
 

bj383ss

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 29, 2011
Messages
3,166
Location
TX
Great update Nick. If your wife's car is going to a flat rate mechanic than they are only going to do what is on the work order for sure.

I love in the one cabinet the "premium" car care is starting to scope creep it looks like. All you need to do is trash all the Meguiars stuff and get some 303 Sealant for UV protection and replace the quick detailer with something from Chemical Guys. :ROFLMAO:

That Rustoleum is really good paint. I suggest next time grabbing some of their self etching primer to throw on bare metal. It will make the paint stick better and adds a moisture barrier under the paint.

Bret
 
OP
N

nicholam77

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 18, 2016
Messages
2,673
Location
Minneapolis, MN
Eh, close enough...

The Ace Hardware in Vermillion, SD (where I lived for ~5 years) is right next to the liquor store as well. They even share a sign...

Funny, it was actually an Ace I was at!

Great update Nick. If your wife's car is going to a flat rate mechanic than they are only going to do what is on the work order for sure.

I love in the one cabinet the "premium" car care is starting to scope creep it looks like. All you need to do is trash all the Meguiars stuff and get some 303 Sealant for UV protection and replace the quick detailer with something from Chemical Guys. :ROFLMAO:

That Rustoleum is really good paint. I suggest next time grabbing some of their self etching primer to throw on bare metal. It will make the paint stick better and adds a moisture barrier under the paint.

Bret

Thanks Bret. Sheeesh, coming out guns blazin' against the Meguiars!! :ROFLMAO:

To be honest I don't have any sort of loyalty to a particular brand of car care products, and I'm not a detailing nut. As evidenced by how often I wash my car. :ROFLMAO: I use the Mequiars Quik Detailer as a lubricant for clay bar, which it seems to work fine for. For an exterior detailer I usually use Adam's Detail Spray. Again, no rhyme or reason against other brands except I'm happy with how it works.

I'm also a fan of the Meguiars Interior Quik Detailer. No odor, no shine, safe on everything.

I've used and do use a handful of Chemical Guys stuff, especially their soaps. My complaint with Chemical Guys is they have sooooooo many dang products, oftentimes advertised to do the same things, it somewhat feels like a ruse. But I like their Mr. Pink soap, and one product I'm a fan of is their Jet Seal, which is synthetic sealant I use instead of wax, twice a year (before and after winter, after a claying). It seems to last much longer than wax, but is applied the same.

I will look into the 303 Sealant as spray and rinse sounds easier.

On the spray paint I assumed I should have done primer, but for whatever reason didn't feel like spending another 10 bucks and hopefully this will last for a bit.

Nice, battery looks brand new now! Good work cleaning that up, and hopefully the problem does not return.

The battery actually is new 😬

There were no functional problems with the old one, but the amount of corrosion all over the surface after only a year seemed completely wrong. I probably could have cleaned up the old one and hoped for the best, but at ~$100 I figured I'd just start fresh.



In other fun car news, the other day I had the windows down in the GTI and was thinking to myself, wow, the turbo really sounds good today! Like, way louder than normal!

Turns out my intake popped off the turbo inlet coupling.

IMG_2199.jpg
IMG_2200.jpg

A bit of a bummer because the diverter valve sounded great with it hanging off! :ROFLMAO:

My intake is just a filter on a stick I got used on a forum, but I'm not happy with the fitment — it rubs, and actually cracked, my engine cover. So I removed the engine cover in the meantime. But the fact that this piping pulled loose and the overall fitment isn't great makes me want to get a different one.

Probably looking at the Integrated Engineering one since they are supposed to sound great and be good quality, but are a bit pricey so I might keep my eye out for a used one.

I also finally attempted to fix the paint chip / rust on my hatch seam.

IMG-2429.jpg
IMG-2430.jpg

In the process I discovered it's down to bare metal in the middle as well, and also on the right side:

IMG-2428.jpg
IMG-2427.jpg

Not as bad or rusty in those areas, but what I've determined is the seam of the hatch is rubbing on the bumper. I can see scratches in the bumper clear coat in those areas.

I painted the problem areas with this stuff @bj383ss recommended:

IMG-2449.jpg

And then went to apply some official VW Carbon Steel Gray + Clear Top Coat touch up pens, but the ones I had were dried up so I need to order some more.

This will give me temporary peace of mind, but I'm not sure how to solve the larger problem of the hatch rubbing on the bumper. And that area collects water and gets so dirty, especially in winter. It's kind of a defect but I'm out of warranty so I don't even know what I'd do (taking to the dealer sounds like a nightmare). But now I'm really worried in a few years my hatch is going to be rusting out.

More updates to come.

🍻
 
OP
N

nicholam77

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 18, 2016
Messages
2,673
Location
Minneapolis, MN
Internet to the Garage!

Awhile ago I got a TP Link Deco X50 Outdoor access point to extend my home network / WiFi to the garage. TP Link's Deco line is a mesh wireless system, and the nodes or access points can be connected wirelessly or over ethernet. Because I had no ethernet in the garage, I had to connect it wirelessly. It did connect... but sometimes the speeds were still very poor, and sometimes it would drop off the mesh altogether:

IMG-2457.jpg

To solve this, I ran ethernet from the house to the garage, which was a bit of a job. First of all, I had to tie into my wired network somewhere. My router base station is in the basement by our main TV, which is on the other side of the wall from my mechanical closet in the laundry room.

IMG-2507.jpg

So I tied into an existing gigabit switch I had behind the TV, and ran it through the wall to the mechanicals closet.

IMG-2508.jpg

The next step was to mount a POE injector in the mechanicals closet. POE (power over ethernet) allows an ethernet cable to supply both network data and power to IoT devices like security cameras, tablets, and even routers. Mine required POE+ which I believe can deliver up to 30W. Basically you plug the ethernet from your network into the injector input port, and then it supplies power and also passes your data to the output port.

My cable from the TV room was way too long, so I had to cut it and re-terminate it with an RJ45 end.

IMG-2501.jpg

If you've never done this, it's not super hard, but kind of fiddly. Most ethernet has 4 pairs of twisted wires. They need to be untwisted, and lined up in a specific order and then pushed into the connector and crimped.

Ethernet-Pin-Out.jpg

There are several versions of this but mine is the T-568B in the diagram above. Line them up, trim them straight, shove in the connector, curse that they didn't insert right, do it 15 more times, and then crimp. :ROFLMAO:

IMG-2504.jpg
IMG-2502.jpg

I always like to use a cable tester and make sure the cable was indeed wired correctly. Basically you attach a device and remote to the respective cable ends, and if all the lights go green and blink in sequence on both ends, you've done it right.

IMG-2506.jpg
IMG-2505.jpg

Here's the full setup inside the furnace closet with the line coming from the TV room, going into the POE+ injector, and then another cable from the injector output going out the side of the house.

IMG-2519.jpg

Which gets us out here:

IMG-2513.jpg

I chose this location because it's where our underground fiber optic internet comes in the house, and there's already a water proofed connection box installed by our ISP.

Checking the 2nd cable I put new ends on (from the POE+ injector to the outside box).

IMG-2517.jpg

So far this has been regular Cat5e.

For the run from the box here to the garage, I'm using exterior-rated direct bury Cat6. The two are connected inside the box with an RJ45 coupler:

IMG-2524.jpg

Before doing the rest of the install, I figured this was a good time to plug in the router and make sure it was working over POE+.

IMG-2523.jpg

And it did!

Re-routed the black Cat6 outdoor cable up through the weather-proof grommet in the bottom of the box and made it all nice and tidy.

IMG-2532.jpg

Now for the fun part. Routing the cable under my sidewalk.

IMG-2528.jpg
IMG-2529.jpg
IMG-2530.jpg

For this I used a 72" flexible 3/4" auger bit I got on Amazon. It still took some time and effort, but much easier than the garden hose method I imagine. I had it routed in about 20min.

Even though this Cat6 cable can be buried, we have a property-dividing fence and I thought it would be much easier to just tack it along the bottom of that with cable clips. The shade garden will hide it.

IMG-2543.jpg

Getting close. Upon inspecting the actual access point to wall mount it on the back of the shed, I realized I had misplaced the wall mount bracket! Another 30min wasted looking for it.

Eventually I found one on Printables for a TP Link Omada unit, and what do you know it fits my Deco X50. 50min later...

IMG-2534.jpg
IMG-2538.jpg

I'm choosing to move the access point outside, and mount on the back of my garden tool shed. I am hoping this will give me good coverage in the back yard, on the patio, and in the garage.

IMG-2541.jpg

Single POE+ Cat6 cable delivering power and data through a water-proofed gasket on the Deco X50:

IMG-2544.jpg

All installed! Below you can see the proximity to the house and to the garage.

IMG-2548.jpg

IMG-2549.jpg

Now, this all doesn't mean :poop: without some speed tests 😁

IMG-2553-edit.jpg

This is just my iPhone connected to WiFi. The left test was inside the garage. The right test was on the patio close to the house.

I'm pretty dang happy with that.

Also, the X50 has a second ethernet port, so in the future I might run another Cat6 cable into the garage for a hardwired computer.

This was practically a full day's worth of work, but it's something I've been wanting to do for a long time so I'm happy to finally have it done! I just hope the little Deco holds up during winter!

🍻
 

sawduststeve

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 7, 2016
Messages
2,139
Location
Havering-Atte-Bower,London/Essex boarders, England
Awesome Nick. Your garage wifi speed is faster than my in house speed. :oops:

Bret
Nick, I agree with Bret, holy cow that’s some great Wi-Fi speed you have there, our house is in a bit of a black hole for all sorts of stuff our down load speed is usually around 16 ( on a good day) and the upload is usually 1.6.
Makes things a little difficult at times 🤣🤣

Steve 🍻
 
OP
N

nicholam77

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 18, 2016
Messages
2,673
Location
Minneapolis, MN
Awesome Nick. Your garage wifi speed is faster than my in house speed. :oops:

Bret

Nick, I agree with Bret, holy cow that’s some great Wi-Fi speed you have there, our house is in a bit of a black hole for all sorts of stuff our down load speed is usually around 16 ( on a good day) and the upload is usually 1.6.
Makes things a little difficult at times 🤣🤣

Steve 🍻

Thanks, guys! Yes, I am very lucky to have several fiber options (I do live in a metro area), but most of all lucky to have a locally-based ISP (not one of the huge corporations like Comcast). They have great customer service, local phone support, and reasonably-priced Gigabit speeds. I keep most things hardwired in my home, so real world speeds are usually 950 Mbps + for most devices.

My work is in video editing and I often have to transfer large bits of data to and from our office when I’m working from home, so the speed is important for that.

What I don’t have is good cell service. Despite having a major cell provider (Verizon) the radius around my neighborhood block is a complete dead zone, so I rely on WiFi calling. This previously made taking a call, looking something up on YouTube, etc very annoying in the garage. Now it should be much better!
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom