OP
Grant Gunderson
Well-known member
As my dad's been aging rather rapidly, I've been having more and more conversations with him and the work that he did as an Engineer, for both the Navy Nuclear power laboratory designing reactors for submarines, to his work at Hanford as anThe thought that continuously pops into my head as I admire your rebuilding skills and attention to detail...is that some people (engineers I suspect) actually sat down with pen and paper and designed this machine. Sure there was probably some trial and error, and modifications from earlier designs..but still 90% of the design is probably from the original right?
I wouldn't short sell your 7 years of training. I'm constantly amazed by what engineers are able to come up with simply with pen and paper. I can fabricate stuff in my garage by trying and bending and reworking stuff by trial and error and make modifications but I can never just sit down and draw stuff that will work ..at least not until after I build it.
Thanks for sharing with us!
Engineer in the 200 area, when they converted from processing plutonium to Nuclear waste around other projects he still wont talk about. I've learned so much from him over the years, from watching him work in his shop as a kid, to now, talking to him about what ever project I am working on and getting his insights and advice. Just when I think I'm getting a good grasp on things, something will casually get mentioned about his past work experiences and I quickly realize I still dont know ****. It's really hard to watch our parents age, and I realize and accept thats a fact of life, but I'm really not looking forward to the day where I cant have my daily calls with him talking about random projects etc and getting his advice and input.... its like there is this immense amount of wisdom I've slowly been tapping into, but I realize I'll never be able appreciate all of it in the time he has left.
The difference and what modern society has lost site of, is these machines where built to do a job I the best way possible, not to a price point. For example, could a bracket be held in place by a couple ⅜ bolts? Sure, but instead of using two bolts, the Monarch also uses two tapper pins in addition to not only secure a bracket but to ensure perfect alignment. It's just a better way of doing things that we have lost in favor of short term profits.It's not as complex, but I have to say I was impressed when I rebuilt my '39 Warner & Swasey turret lathe. Those guys knew how to build a machine that lasts. Mine's eighty-plus years old, and has certainly made hundreds of thousands of parts- and save for a few places, it's still tight as a drum.
The turret locking mechanism is solid as a rock, there's zero play in the spindle, there's no appreciable wear in the collet mechanism (originally a motorized, power collet closer, which I converted to manual since the motor was missing) the sliding ways for the turret ram are smooth as glass and show very little wear (although they're replaceable, and it's certainly possible they were at some point replaced) the power feed gear drive for the ram works smoothly and perfectly in all gears, the feed clutch works perfectly...
Compare something like that, or Grant's 10EE, to even a $10K modern import, and it's night and day.
Doc.
While a modern CNC machine, can be more efficient and accurate, none of them can hold the tolerances for decades and decades like the high-end old iron can. Modern machines are built to be disposed of, not to keep working.
What a lot of people dont realize is the 10EE was the machine that made the Atomic era possible. It was the one of the only machines that was capable of manufacturing the fuel rods to a high enough precision, as well as one of the only machine that was capable of accurate machining the Plutonium cores for the nuclear arsenal.
I've been told Monarch still builds and sales the 10EE to custom order for smoothing like $250K+






























































































































































































































































