Am I going to be in legal jeopardy in the inevitable upcoming lawsuit?
We accomplices can request adjacent cells, Don. Plenty of original paperbacks to read. And when we kiss our wives goodbye, they can pass us files from our tiny tools collections.
The ebay sellers claiming "copyright" on those photocopied catalog pages... is laughable.
As laughable as the guys compiling photocopied catalog pages onto CDs and claiming copyright on the CDs to try to prevent people from copying and sharing the CD so they can continue to bilk people $100 a pop for them.
It's the "fair use" clause.
If you haven't been following, IA lost a major court battle just last year where the judge in the case called the fair use argument "unpersuasive," IA appealed, and just a few weeks ago the US Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit upheld the district court ruling. Search on
Hachette v. Internet Archive. It affects only a special offshoot called the National Emergency Library that IA launched in 2020 during the Big C era that basically relaxed the 'one book, one person at a time' method for lending contemporary copyrighted books. Not a fan of big publishers, but Hachette, joined by HarperCollins, Penguin Random House, and others were right in this case, I thought. IA is also being sued for a music digitization project that skirts with piracy. I do wish they'd tone all that **** down.
Most of the volumes and texts and access to them are safe, especially those to the left of the copyright barrier, and even many of those to the right of it, ******* with Google Books, HathiTrust and a host of major college libraries. I am pretty sure ITCL is in that wing. I just hope that cutting the legs off the venturous shenanigans doesn't cripple the whole thing. A prominent part of the threatening category is the AI wave. Large Language Models rely on a large corpus of data for scouring, but what the overzealous copyright hawks (aided by plain old greedy MFers) are aiming at, are implicit infringements in the summaries without citations.
Having said all that, I don't see it all coming to an end any time soon. In fact, the history of all these suits is the aggrieved parties ironically not really wanting to win or lose, just take their settlement pay out and quietly skulk away without anyone noticing, because in many cases, the books are out of print, and there is little to no revenue stream.