shoturtle
Well-known member
Not the big stuff.
Also worth noting the SK and the Proto will bottom on the head of a bolt or nut. The Armstorng/Craftsman do not have this feature. Making it extremely difficult to start a bolt or nut from the socket as it will fall into the socket. This is why I have always disliked Craftsman sockets.
Good comparison. Thanks!
I just saying that sk is not in the same league.
are you saying Armstrong is rebranded craftsman. I'm not saying craftsman is bad. I actually think their sockets are by far the best value you can buy especially considering warranty. But i dont see how you can say craftsman is even on par with sk as far as looks. Performance you cannot argue because you have no data to back up. I cannot eitherAs much as the sk is nice product. It is not better then the armstrong aka craftman. I have used them. And there is really nothing that they offer that are any better then the armstrong or craftman. Strenght wise the craftsman and armstrong do hold up very well.
The extra cost it the precieve quality of the brand name, not the actually quality of the tool. To me pretty chrome does not equate the for extra cost.
To be honest the only set in this group that is worth the extra money really is the proto. I use them at work, and they are better then william, armstrong, and sk sockets we have at work.
I got the each set, Proto, Armstrong and SK all for $80-$90 each. That's less than Snap-On any day of the week. Of course if you pay full retail price then you're still less but close to Snap-On prices. Your 49 piece set for $130 is a great price.
are you saying Armstrong is rebranded craftsman. I'm not saying craftsman is bad. I actually think their sockets are by far the best value you can buy especially considering warranty. But i dont see how you can say craftsman is even on par with sk as far as looks. Performance you cannot argue because you have no data to back up. I cannot either
The craftsman and Armstrong I have are almost exact but the Armstrong is slightly brighter, a tad less brown. It could be the chrome mixture used or each batch.
can I ask where you bought the proto. Only place I could really find was Grainger which is pretty much full blown retail. I need a good 3/8 set and was gonna go with sk but would definately entertain proto especially if the prices are similar. Also if you could tell me where you got the Armstrong id appreciate it. I have only 1 Armstrong tool( a 1/4 locking flex head ratchet) and i love it. Not even a comparison to the craftsman flex head i have
Some older SK sockets were cold broached. Not any better than how craftsman sockets are formed...just different and one could be better worse depending on what the mfg specs and produces. The less deep broaching makes them a little stronger I suppose....but how much torque are you putting on small 1/4" drive fasteners?
To me, that's the problem with all threads like this one. All opinion with little or no facts supplied to support those opinions other then the occasional anecdotal tidbits thrown in for flavor.There's no objective information in this post, just you claiming that you think Proto is better than SK and SK is the same quality as Craftsman. There's nothing to back up those claims. Plus you have no objective info to say why the Proto is better.
There's actually no objective information posted by anyone in this thread
You keep on forgetting Williams. They are the number 2 brand along with Proto for industrial use in my area.When it comes to industrial high torque application that is fact that the big players are Proto, Wright, Apex, and Snap On. Not all companies play in the big industrial end. And it is simple fact is SK does not play in the industrial level sockets. They were never design to handle the torque of modern bolt superstructure construction. The other companies have whole divisions focus on that.
You keep on forgetting Williams. They are the number 2 brand along with Proto for industrial use in my area.
Now that's good info there. Please report back once you get the replacements and let us know how they turn out?OK, so I contacted all three companies about warranty. My experience was this:
So what tools do you own? Surely not Snap-On based on your comments.Or do you just like having every type of socket in you tool box, 6 and 12 pt from 1/4"-2 3/8" in 1/4, 3/8, 1/2 & 3/4" drives?
I have 40 year old SK and Billings sockets. Do I care if it has a offset sizing stamp? No. Do I care that it doesn't crack at 150 foot pounds, you're damn right I care. I have Bonney wrenches with the name in two different heights. If they were still in business, would i send them back? No. As long as the wrench does it's job, who cares.
These are sockets, which are tools. Your comparison is closer to a woman shopping for a diamond than how good the socket is.
So what tools do you own? Surely not Snap-On based on your comments.
If all you care about is not cracking at 150 foot pounds then you might as well stop wasting your money on good tools! Buy taiwan or china made stuff. I'm sure any of their 3/8" sockets can handle more than 150 ft lbs! I'm sure you have other reasons for not buying china stuff than being strong enough for your jobs? no?
I don't have many tools, just enough to do what I need which is mainly work on my metric Porsche. Grease is fine, but rust doesn't belong on a car or a tool. And if you work in the places I do, you'd know that all tools get wiped down before being put away and rust isn't allowed.
What you fail to realize it that some of us don't give a damn about diamonds, but we expect our tools to be manufactured to the highest standards of quality and cosmetic perfection. People like you will never understand that.



Come on, you guys are taking this socket comparison stuff waay too seriously.
Buy a rack of each and use them!!!! see what breaks and what doesn't. Buy more of the stuff that doesn't break.
Scratches, nicks, and a little rust to a degree are Patina!! Like callouses and scars on a mechanics hands/arms. Remember chicks dig scars. fasteners don't care how shiny the socket is that touches them.
I know this is America and it's more important to look good than to perform well but, that doesn't apply to tools.
Tools are meant to be used and abused, not participate in a concours de elegance for chrome.
Now get your damn tools dirty by using the hell out of them, and have a great 4th of July.![]()
theres two types of people.
Those who work with their tools.
Those who play with their tools.
You use them on a metric Porsche, big deal. I use them on farm equipment, farm tractors, snowmobile, chainsaws and an American muscle car, among other things. Who cares?
A torque to yield test would be a better comparison than how pretty the chrome is.....
bob