With my situation I tend to get paralyzed due to over complication. As an example if I want to organize my bolts, I have a very hard time labeling a drawer 1/4" and putting all the 1/4" bolts and associated hardware in it. My brain fights with me, almost as if I am not telling the truth, in my head I want a label for specifics. So my labels would be grade 5, 1/4" x 20 thread, 3/4" length, color, head type. I "want" to do this for every bolt, washer, nut, even if I only have one. Because I can't do that, I just give up and leave them wherever. Even worse I will organize things one way, then forget how I organized them when I come back, then I have to start over.
I have actually started a drawer that is labeled 1/4", but when I go in it, there is a lot of other hardware not related. To some it is easy to do this, I just can't get around this mentally.
When a organizer says one home for everything, that boggles my mind. I have so many things that are multipurpose, I remember trying to do this, I bought a dozen pairs of scissors to keep them in the proper areas, after a while I lost all 12 and wasted hours of time looking for them, only to end up buying more anyways. I try and keep things simplified, but it is very hard. I am hoping to be able to find a middle ground so I don't have to argue with myself so much. This winter should be a good test as I am ready to organize my stuff, I have plenty of drawers, shelves, bins, and labels.