To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Speedy's Garage 3.0

Speedy!

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 23, 2014
Messages
271
Location
TN
I'm preparing to start a garage build and this forum was recommended by a friend (Toofart) to check out to get ideas. The garage will be detached and 24W x 34L. I'm planning a single 18" wide garage door facing front and a man door on the left side (as your facing the garage). The garage will be used as parking and an automotive work area. Planning a 2 post Bendpak lift down the road placed in the back right corner.

I got 4 quotes and the original builder of the home was actually the best by far, and they were pretty good to work with building the house. They're still building in the neighborhood so the contractors on on site and likely helped with the pricing. It will be 100% brick with double windows on each side and in the back, and a single window above the garage door. Shingle, brick, mortar, gutters, eaves, etc will all match the house per HOA requirements. I'm gonna have them put in a half bath and a shop sink as well as heat and air. 13' 6" ceilings to accommodate the lift.

I had the house built about 4 years ago with a nice 3 car garage and thought I'd be all set. The house I moved from was built by the same builder and had an attached 2 car garage that measured 24W x 24L. I had several vehicles and got tired of playing musical cars in the driveway so I had the new place built. Low and behold the new garage, while nice and 3 cars wide, was built 18 feet deep. My Challenger BARELY fits. A 3 car looks huge until you start pulling a big car like a Challenger in to it with tool boxes and a work bench in front :3gears: It has heat/air, lots of lights, etc but I need more room so it will be relegated to parking only for the most part.

Here's the current garage. 3 cars is nice, but it needed to be about 6 feet deeper.

speedys_garage_20_05.jpg


speedys_garage_20_11.jpg


18,000 BTU TPAC - works great to cool this space down to 70ish degrees in 90+ temps with 60% humidity.

speedys_garage_20_08.jpg


One of the best things I did - satellite in the shop. I wear out Alt Nation on Sirius. New shop will have this for sure.
speedys_garage_20_09.jpg


I need to figure out lighting, storage, power outlets, TV connection, floor coating, etc. After the garage on the house being too shallow I'm paranoid I'll miss something on the new one. Time to do some reading :rocker:

So far I'm thinking Ucoatit for the floor. I have a buddy that does commercial lighting design for a living so I'm gonna get him to do up a lighting design for me. I don't know if it'll be canned lights or tube florescents, but it'll be a tiered approach where I can flip on the lights in 3 stages depending on how bright I need it to be. It'll be fully insulated and finished inside as well.

I'll post pics as I get it started. Time to do some reading. I'd love to hear some lessons learned from folks that have already been down this road.

Update 5/3/2015

I've finalized the garage size and layout. It will now be 24x34 which is about the biggest I can fit on my property and meet codes. You guys were right, bigger is always better when it comes to the shop :)

Met with the builder yesterday and got the layout down on the property, they got the project in queue, and should start pouring footers and the pad in the next couple of weeks. He's wanting to set the garage back from the end of the driveway 2 feet to allow for a grade as you enter the garage, kind of a small concrete ramp if you will that has a rise of about 2 inches over the 2' span. He says this will avoid any water issues. I'm wondering if that's the best solution, or have it **** against the driveway and install a channel drain?

The concrete will be 4" thick 3500 with two 3' x 3' pads that are 8" think incorporated where the lift posts will go. I'll start posting pics once they start work.

Updated 7/21/2015 with a detailed sketch of garage layout:

garage_layout.jpg


Update 8/1/2015

Here's the giant sign that had to be placed on my front yard for 30 days to get the city variance to build the garage the size I wanted. Went through unanimously no problem on the city vote. Bottom line, make sure you cross check EVERYTHING before starting a project like this. This held me up about 6 weeks as I got some incorrect information from the city inspector.

speedysgarage_appeal_sign_web.jpg


Staked out the location. This caused a massive fight with a neighbor who's an attorney and threatened to sue me. Once she learned the city had approved she didn't want to continue the fight :) Not sure how she missed that sign in my front yard but she claimed to not have been informed. Meh. She and her husband must not communicate either as he and I had discussed it for months.

speedysgarage_30_01_web.jpg


Silt fence installed.

speedysgarage_30_02_web.jpg


Footer dug.

speedysgarage_30_03_web.jpg


And poured.

speedysgarage_30_04_web.jpg


Update 8/16/2015

Foundation block was delivered this week.

speedysgarage_30_05_web.jpg


The corners laid out and the foundation started. The builder gave me a little extra width, as much as would fit on the footer making the brick to brick 24'8".

speedysgarage_30_06_web.jpg


speedysgarage_30_07_web.jpg


They also went ahead and put in a few rows of brick on one side so they can grade that part of the garage. The builder told me they're trying to be careful with the yard and general "mess" to avoid as much inconvenience as possible. Some tubing was also installed for water/electric from the house to run through.

speedysgarage_30_08_web.jpg


Update 9/20/2015

After more delays than I was happy with due to equipment malfunctions and some other properties the builder has been working on I made a call to my Realtor who lit a fire and got them moving again. For three weeks no work was done, then more was done in a single week than during the whole build so far. Concrete should be poured tomorrow.

The broken down excavator was finally repaired and delivered to clean up the area.

speedysgarage_30_09_web.jpg


Excavated, leveled, and drains installed as a precaution.

speedysgarage_30_10_web.jpg


Gravel poured

speedysgarage_30_12_web.jpg


Plumbing prepped for the bathroom/ shop sink.

speedysgarage_30_14_web.jpg


Floor drain installed

speedysgarage_30_13_web.jpg


Recesses dug out for 8 inch thick 36"x36" pads for 2 post lift location. Concrete will be 4,000 psi 4" thick and 8" think in these two areas.

speedysgarage_30_15_web.jpg


Update 10/3/2015

Been a bit busy, so this will be a pretty big update.

Concrete poured (4,000 PSI 4" thick except where lift posts will be and that's 8")

speedysgarage_30_16_web.jpg


Christened :)

speedysgarage_30_17_web.jpg


Frame package delivered

speedysgarage_30_18_web.jpg


Framing started

speedysgarage_30_19_web.jpg


And finished

speedysgarage_30_20_web.jpg


Closet for compressor

speedysgarage_30_21_web.jpg


And restroom

speedysgarage_30_22_web.jpg


Man door

speedysgarage_30_23_web.jpg


Roofing completed (architectural to match the house)

speedysgarage_30_24_web.jpg


Electrical roughed in (house upgraded to 400A service with a dedicated box in the shop)

speedysgarage_30_25_web.jpg


5 gang switch box by man door. Lights are wired in 2 banks on 3-ways to 5 gang by compressor room. Switches for exterior door lights, cans, and attic which will be illuminated so I don't forget to turn it off.


speedysgarage_30_26_web.jpg


5 gang at compressor room. Light bank 1 and 2 - 3-ways; light/fan combo fan, light, and finally a switch to turn on compressor. The light and compressor switch will be illuminated on so I don't forget to turn them off.


speedysgarage_30_27_web.jpg



4 20A outlets on one side, 5 on the other, and 4 on the back wall.

speedysgarage_30_28_web.jpg


..............continued later in thread, this post hit the character limit :(
 
Last edited:
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

drivesitfar

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 23, 2013
Messages
35,997
Location
Pacific Northwest
Re: New detached garage in the works

Speedy: while costs for most of us are always an issue can i suggest building as big of a shop as you can afford or that the city will allow. reason being that we all run out of space eventually. post up questions as you wish to on your thread here after reading a lot of threads on the garage gallery because there are a lot of great garages over there.

welcome to our forum

DP: i think Speedy's new garage is 22 foot wide and 34 foot deep, but you are right bigger is usually better.
 
OP
S

Speedy!

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 23, 2014
Messages
271
Location
TN
Re: New detached garage in the works

Yep, bigger is always better when it comes to garages. 22W x 34L is the biggest I can fit on my property according to city code.
 

drivesitfar

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 23, 2013
Messages
35,997
Location
Pacific Northwest
Re: New detached garage in the works

Speedy: well then is it as high as you can go so it won't look awkward next to the house? sounds like you have the size figured out now for the insides.

plenty of power and can you get the garage it's own service (meter)? some guys like 3 phase vs. VFD in case you have some big machines you want to buy and use. i'll keep watching and any pictures you have of your lot and existing house to post would be great too.

the link in you signature line works because i came here from your last post in the introduction thread.

good luck
 

sd171

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 3, 2010
Messages
135
Location
South Dakota
Re: New detached garage in the works

I just built a 24' wide x 34' deep detached garage with an 18' x 8' garage door that you might find helpful. It sounds to me like you are trying to fit quite a lot into a limited space: parking, workshop, lift, bathroom, high ceiling. You may be able to fit all of those, but I don't think you will also be able to fit a staircase and attic with comfortable headroom. It amazes me how quickly my own space started shrinking once I parked two cars in it.

After starting to use my garage, I can say that I would never want a garage door smaller than 18' x 8'. It's also nice to have a 24' wide structure because one of my parking spaces requires a diagonal approach and the front bumper swings wide of the garage door opening while inside the garage.
 
Last edited:

chops101

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 15, 2013
Messages
554
Location
S. FL
Re: New detached garage in the works

Musical cars - I like that, know exactly what you've been through.

I'm retrofitting a 24 x 32 shop (has no garage doors on it presently) but I'm going with (2) 9x8 doors, mainly due to ease of re-construction without doing major bond beam overhaul.
 
OP
S

Speedy!

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 23, 2014
Messages
271
Location
TN
Re: New detached garage in the works

Speedy: well then is it as high as you can go so it won't look awkward next to the house? sounds like you have the size figured out now for the insides.

plenty of power and can you get the garage it's own service (meter)? some guys like 3 phase vs. VFD in case you have some big machines you want to buy and use. i'll keep watching and any pictures you have of your lot and existing house to post would be great too.

the link in you signature line works because i came here from your last post in the introduction thread.

good luck

I think with the 13'6" ceilings it's as tall as i can make it without it looking funny. There's also a city code with some limit I can't go over for height. 28' is in my head but that may not be exactly right.

The garage will have it's own power. The house will be upgraded to 400A service and the garage box tied off of that. The biggest thing I can see me needing is a small welder, so I'll check with the electrician to make sure I have enough for that. Gonna have 4 220V outlets and probably 20 120 V ones.

Here are is a picture of the house and the area the garage will live at the end of the drive. The sidewalk may get moved closer to the house to give room for more width, that is TBD.

house1_small.JPG


house2_small.jpg


I'll be following your progress. You will be happy with an 18' door.

Yep, 18' single door will work best for me.

Have you thought about trying to get a variance ?

I am going to ask about that. I'd really like a 24x34.

I just built a 24' wide x 34' deep detached garage with an 18' x 8' garage door that you might find helpful. It sounds to me like you are trying to fit quite a lot into a limited space: parking, workshop, lift, bathroom, high ceiling. You may be able to fit all of those, but I don't think you will also be able to fit a staircase and attic with comfortable headroom. It amazes me how quickly my own space started shrinking once I parked two cars in it.

After starting to use my garage, I can say that I would never want a garage door smaller than 18' x 8'. It's also nice to have a 24' wide structure because one of my parking spaces requires a diagonal approach and the front bumper swings wide of the garage door opening while inside the garage.

I'll go check out your build thread. The bathroom may just become a wall attached urinal if it starts taking up too much space haha. I'm gonna have to see on that. The attic will be strictly for storing car parts, so as long as I can shove them up there I'm not overly concerned. The lift and workshop area are concerns though. The lift I've been eyeballing is the Bendpak XPR-10A-LP. It requires 4' in front, 4' in back and a 1' perimeter around the posts. Posts are also 11' apart so that's gonna take up A LOT of space. I planned to have it offset toward the right and toward the rear of he garage. Tool boxes will be in the back right corner and a work bend on the right hand wall as well. Air compressor in the back right corner as well. At least that's the plan, I'm still making drawings to see what would be the best layout.

One car will be parked in the shop, that being the Challenger. I won't need much parking space since I have a 3 car attached already. As long as I can park one car and still have room for the lift and work shop I'll be happy.
 
OP
S

Speedy!

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 23, 2014
Messages
271
Location
TN
Re: New detached garage in the works

I've been playing around with some layout sketches on graph paper with one square = 1 foot. I've talked to the contractor and I think we can go as wide as 24 making the size 24x36. This width will eliminate the mulch bed against the house, not a big deal as nothing would grow there anyway in so much shade, and leave about a 6' wide concrete sidewalk between the house and garage.

Here's what I've sketched out placement wise to make sure the lift, bathroom, sink, work benches, etc would all fit and it looks OK to me. If you guys see something I should be considering I'd be interested to hear it. Obviously some cabinets will be hung on some walls, and I'm not sure if I'll eliminate the side windows to give more wall hanging space for shelves and cabinets or not.

Updated first post with sketch.
 
Last edited:

sd171

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 3, 2010
Messages
135
Location
South Dakota
Re: New detached garage in the works

Obviously some cabinets will be hung on some walls, and I'm not sure if I'll eliminate the side windows to give more wall hanging space for shelves and cabinets or not.

I have two double windows in the ground floor of my garage on the south wall, and they are definitely worth the loss of wall space. With good natural light, good overhead light, HVAC and music I can spend all day in the garage without complaint. I recommend putting two windows in one wall - preferably a wall with a view and good light. You can fit a surprising number of cabinets around the windows, and you could still have two unobstructed walls for storage if you are concerned about wall space.
 

Rosco

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 4, 2009
Messages
1,140
Location
South Georgia
Re: New detached garage in the works

I say to definitely put the toilet in. I have a 1/2 bath under my stairwell to the upstairs and love it. If you leave it out, you will definitely find something to fill the space. If you install it, you will learn to work around it.

Use a pocket door to cut down on space.
 
OP
S

Speedy!

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 23, 2014
Messages
271
Location
TN
Re: New detached garage in the works

You'll see in the drawing a double wide window at the back of the shop. That overlooks a nice pond surrounded by a white picket fence. The one on the west wall will only have a view of the bricks on the house. The one on the east wall will have a view of my neighbors yard. Those are the two I'm considering eliminating for extra wall space. Will see how much it saves or costs doing so, I suspect it would be a wash really though.
 
OP
S

Speedy!

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 23, 2014
Messages
271
Location
TN
Re: New detached garage in the works

Ok need some guidance. Builder did some checking and has found a potential issue. The garage is level with the house so sinks and toilet can't gravity feed to sewer for the house. He tells me this increases cost substantially to have those items in the garage as they have to use a grinder pump and special plumbing to get the waste water over to the house sewer line. Looks to increase cost about $5K. Does that seem right and are there any concerns with this design in terms of long term maintenance or headaches?

I'm now wondering if I should skip the sink and toilet in the detached garage. I have a shop sink in the 3 car attached garage that will be a 10 second walk away, but toilets are obviously inside the house.
 

Onewolf

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 15, 2012
Messages
371
Location
East Central Florida
Re: New detached garage in the works

It cost about $2500 for sewer lift pump (macerator) and installation for my current DG build. I would have preferred gravity sewer, but that wasn't possible. I started with 1/2 bath and ended up with full bath thanks to GarageJournal forums. :)
 

smttysmth02gt

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 13, 2015
Messages
65
Location
Gulf Coast (AL)
Re: New detached garage in the works

I would like to have those things in my shop as well, but tbh not if it means adding another $5k on top of what I was already spending. Have you tried getting another quote from someone else to make sure he's not taking advantage to make more $?
 

zmotorsports

ALLIANCE MEMBER
Joined
Oct 20, 2009
Messages
21,312
Location
Northern Utah
Re: New detached garage in the works

Subscribed. Want to watch the progress/build.

Personally, I would scratch the bathroom but that is just me. Mine is 34'x34' and chucked full. At first I wanted a bathroom in there but was as large a shop as I could go as per the city ordinance.

I opted to pass on the bathroom, I figured if I needed to go I had two in the house. It is a PITA to remove coveralls, remove shoes and go in to use the restroom but in the end I much prefer having more space in the shop. I don't know of any tools I would be without in order to have a restroom in the corner.

Just my opinion.

Mike.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

rburke65

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 10, 2007
Messages
12,349
Location
Canfield, Ohio
Re: New detached garage in the works

As said, bigger is always better, but I'm happy with my 32' depth of my shop. I have a 2 post lift with a box in front of it and room to work around a long '65 Impala. Good luck!
 
OP
S

Speedy!

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 23, 2014
Messages
271
Location
TN
Re: New detached garage in the works

I would like to have those things in my shop as well, but tbh not if it means adding another $5k on top of what I was already spending. Have you tried getting another quote from someone else to make sure he's not taking advantage to make more $?

I got 5 quotes and the guys who built my home were the best price by 25%. The fact they built my current house I know the level of work they're capable of.

Only one tool box?:D

That's for starters :)

As said, bigger is always better, but I'm happy with my 32' depth of my shop. I have a 2 post lift with a box in front of it and room to work around a long '65 Impala. Good luck!

How much room did you leave in front of your two post to the tool box? I've planned for 9 feet to the wall and a tool box on casters so I can move it around if needed.
 
OP
S

Speedy!

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 23, 2014
Messages
271
Location
TN
Re: New detached garage in the works

Update 5/3/2015

I've finalized the garage size and layout. It will now be 24x34 which is about the biggest I can fit on my property and meet codes. You guys were right, bigger is always better when it comes to the shop. Image on first post updated to show layout.

Met with the builder yesterday and got the layout down on the property, they got the project in queue, and should start pouring footers and the pad in the next couple of weeks. He's wanting to set the garage back from the end of the driveway 2 feet to allow for a grade as you enter the garage, kind of a small concrete ramp if you will that has a rise of about 2 inches over the 2' span. He says this will avoid any water issues. I'm wondering if that's the best solution, or have it **** against the driveway and install a channel drain?

The concrete will be 4" thick 3500 with two 3' x 3' pads that are 8" think incorporated where the lift posts will go. I'll start posting pics once they start work.
 
OP
S

Speedy!

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 23, 2014
Messages
271
Location
TN
Re: New detached garage in the works

Welp, a wrinkle. It seems in my area codes require detached structures to be "behind" the house. This means my garage would have to be built 32 feet back from the end of the driveway where I intended it to go, which means a large concrete pad be poured concreting almost my entire back yard.

I've contacted the city and am in the process of getting a variance. Wish me luck. More to come......
 

zmotorsports

ALLIANCE MEMBER
Joined
Oct 20, 2009
Messages
21,312
Location
Northern Utah
Re: New detached garage in the works

Welp, a wrinkle. It seems in my area codes require detached structures to be "behind" the house. This means my garage would have to be built 32 feet back from the end of the driveway where I intended it to go, which means a large concrete pad be poured concreting almost my entire back yard.

I've contacted the city and am in the process of getting a variance. Wish me luck. More to come......

I had to do the same thing on mine. It had to be separated by about 20 or so feet if memory serves. Which was fine with me because I wanted it tucked back into the corner as much as possible anyhow. Mine is only 34'x34' and is about 35' from the back door of my house garage. I actually like it offset like that. It is far enough away without being too far away. Noises, fumes and vibrations from the shop never reach the house yet a short stroll out the back door. I don't know if I would want it any other way to be honest.

Good luck and report back.

Mike.
 

bczygan

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 4, 2009
Messages
22,002
Location
DETROIT! Arsenal of Scrappers
Re: New detached garage in the works

Welp, a wrinkle. It seems in my area codes require detached structures to be "behind" the house. This means my garage would have to be built 32 feet back from the end of the driveway where I intended it to go, which means a large concrete pad be poured concreting almost my entire back yard.

I've contacted the city and am in the process of getting a variance. Wish me luck. More to come......

Thanks for the object lesson.

This is why the very FIRST thing anyone should do, when planning any construction, is to check their zoning, and read and understand all the ZONING rules.

These are what define and constrain what and where you can build. How big and high and close to the property lines and existing structures.

Finding these things out when ready to begin construction is WAY too late.

In many places, variances are expensive, difficult and impossible to get.

So everyone, please, before you dream of how big a space you want, or what you want to put in it, just look up your zoning on the zoning map and look at the zoning rules for that zoning. Save yourself the grief and disappointment, and cost.
 

jmarkwolf

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 15, 2013
Messages
1,809
Location
Southeast Michigan
Re: New detached garage in the works

My first incliniation upon seeing your layout sketch, and I don't know if it's possible in your scenario, is to change the orientation of the building 90degrees, put the main door on the long wall, add a single-wide 2nd door, and you'll be able to fit more cars and toys. Always desirable.

Also, since space is always at a premium, use the space for the sink for a parts washer instead, and use the "facilities" in the house for hand washing. Got a laundry tub in the house? The wife probably won't mind if it get's a little grungy.
 
OP
S

Speedy!

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 23, 2014
Messages
271
Location
TN
Re: New detached garage in the works

I had to do the same thing on mine. It had to be separated by about 20 or so feet if memory serves. Which was fine with me because I wanted it tucked back into the corner as much as possible anyhow. Mine is only 34'x34' and is about 35' from the back door of my house garage. I actually like it offset like that. It is far enough away without being too far away. Noises, fumes and vibrations from the shop never reach the house yet a short stroll out the back door. I don't know if I would want it any other way to be honest.

Good luck and report back.

Mike.

With the way our neighborhood is setup, having it in the back corner will look really odd, but if they make me do it I'm going to. Everyone I've talked to so far has said the variance should be no problem.

Thanks for the object lesson.

This is why the very FIRST thing anyone should do, when planning any construction, is to check their zoning, and read and understand all the ZONING rules.

These are what define and constrain what and where you can build. How big and high and close to the property lines and existing structures.

Finding these things out when ready to begin construction is WAY too late.

In many places, variances are expensive, difficult and impossible to get.

So everyone, please, before you dream of how big a space you want, or what you want to put in it, just look up your zoning on the zoning map and look at the zoning rules for that zoning. Save yourself the grief and disappointment, and cost.

Good points. The problem is unless you're a builder or sub contractor I found it VERY difficult to get straight information on this prior to starting. I talked directly to the inspector and none of this was ever mentioned, only that it had to be 10 feet from the neighbors property, and 15 feet from the rear property line. I would have hoped the builder doing the work, who also has built about 30 houses in this subdivision, or the inspector I spoke with would have mentioned something as large as this during the planning discussions that have gone on for several months. Oh well, learn something every day.

Variance application is $100 and I've already got it filed. Will have to wait to the next city board meeting in June to have it heard though.
 

bczygan

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 4, 2009
Messages
22,002
Location
DETROIT! Arsenal of Scrappers
Re: New detached garage in the works

With the way our neighborhood is setup, having it in the back corner will look really odd, but if they make me do it I'm going to. Everyone I've talked to so far has said the variance should be no problem.



Good points. The problem is unless you're a builder or sub contractor I found it VERY difficult to get straight information on this prior to starting. I talked directly to the inspector and none of this was ever mentioned, only that it had to be 10 feet from the neighbors property, and 15 feet from the rear property line. I would have hoped the builder doing the work, who also has built about 30 houses in this subdivision, or the inspector I spoke with would have mentioned something as large as this during the planning discussions that have gone on for several months. Oh well, learn something every day.

Variance application is $100 and I've already got it filed. Will have to wait to the next city board meeting in June to have it heard though.

People always think the building inspector is the go to person for planning questions. He is NOT! He may know some stuff, he may know a lot, but it is the ZONING department that is where you need to go.

Most jurisdictions have the zoning map and zoning regulations online. Find out who handles your zoning, and go look. Note that in some places one jurisdiction will do planning and zoning, and another will do building inspection. Find out who is who for you.

And a builder builds. He would assume that all the planning had been done, to meet all requirements, prior to drawing submission for permits. Your particular lot may have different zoning rules depending on the classification. Some places have 3 or 4 different residential zoning classifications.

Just remember that planning comes first. Zoning tells you WHAT you can do and WHERE you can do it. Building is where you show HOW you are building it. After approval, they then inspect, to make sure you met all the zoning and building requirements that were approved on the plans.

To make things easier for approvals, I always showed on the drawings, the zoning and zoning requirements for the particular property, along with all setbacks, easements and area calculations. Makes approvals quicker too.
 
Last edited:
OP
S

Speedy!

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 23, 2014
Messages
271
Location
TN
Re: New detached garage in the works

Good stuff, should help someone in the future. A bit late for me LOL

I'm working directly with the zoning department and city planner at this point. The builder has built just about every home in this neighborhood and I went through the same realtor I used for the house who works with them. Lesson learned on who to talk to :)

I guess what I'm getting at is that I'm not a builder or contractor and have no clue how the process works. Builders are in the business to make money, and I'd think it would behoove them to be up on what you can and can't do to make projects go more smoothly. They risk projects being cancelled over things like these. I did my due diligence, and am I highly detailed person, and I missed this. I feel for folks who just don't have any clue what so ever. When I called the city to get information, I contacted the folks they instructed me to and apparently that was the wrong guy, or he should have directed me to the codes dept. I've figured it out now, but the chances of me ever needing this again are about 0.
 
Last edited:

bczygan

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 4, 2009
Messages
22,002
Location
DETROIT! Arsenal of Scrappers
Re: New detached garage in the works

Yeah, I hate to see what happened to you. That's why I toot the horn whenever I can,

Good that you're working with zoning and planning directly, but usually they aren't the ones who approve or deny. Usually there is a zoning board of appeals. But getting the zoning and planning guys in your camp is important.

Sometimes they have informal review sessions available, where you can go over your plans and kind of pitch them, and see what will be accepted in the formal review before the city with the public in attendance.

You want to get the city planner and zoning guys on your side, so when it is presented to the zoning board of appeals, you have their support. They can help sway the ZBA or block you.

Do your politicking with the neighbors. Bringing the closest ones to you, with you to the meeting, in full support of your plan, can help a lot. They will all be notified as part of the process, usually everyone within 300'.

I've done a few of these, even with unbuildable lots, and got approvals. On the other hand, you must show a hardship (Not financial), and also show there is no reasonable alternative. Showing similar solutions nearby can help, but they may also be grandfathered. Try to find the reasoning behind the rule, and if you can accommodate the reasoning, while breaking the rule, it can also help.

A variance is never a slam dunk, and usually only one chance, so get all your ducks in a row.
 
Last edited:
OP
S

Speedy!

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 23, 2014
Messages
271
Location
TN
Re: New detached garage in the works

Yeah, I hate to see what happened to you. That's why I toot the horn whenever I can,

Good that you're working with zoning and planning directly, but usually they aren't the ones who approve or deny. Usually there is a zoning board of appeals. But getting the zoning and planning guys in your camp is important.

Sometimes they have informal review sessions available, where you can go over your plans and kind of pitch them, and see what will be accepted in the formal review before the city with the public in attendance.

You want to get the city planner and zoning guys on your side, so when it is presented to the zoning board of appeals, you have their support. They can help sway the ZBA or block you.

Do your politicking with the neighbors. Bringing the closest ones to you, with you to the meeting, in full support of your plan, can help a lot. They will all be notified as part of the process, usually everyone within 300'.

I've done a few of these, even with unbuildable lots, and got approvals. On the other hand, you must show a hardship (Not financial), and also show there is no reasonable alternative. Showing similar solutions nearby can help, but they may also be grandfathered. Try to find the reasoning behind the rule, and if you can accommodate the reasoning, while breaking the rule, it can also help.

A variance is never a slam dunk, and usually only one chance, so get all your ducks in a row.

Thanks for all the help. I've started "campaigning" as it were and so far have only had one person concerned. The husband is all for it, the wife is worried about it blocking the sun in the afternoon. I was nice, but told her she'd need to decide where she'd prefer the sun to be blocked....next to the house or her back yard as the garage WILL go in one of two places :)

Everyone else is like hell yeah man, it needs to go at the end of the driveway, so that's a good sign. Not sure how the hearing goes, but I do have to be there. I think it's the 2nd Tuesday in June. I'm going to take this experience and learn from it and maybe I can use it to help someone in the future.

I battled with my Challenger all day yesterday working on the brake system and didn't quite get finished. What a drag having to put the car back together, unfinished, put all the tools away, etc so my wife could park. With the shop, I could've just left it like it was and closed the door. Strengthened my resolve to get this done one way or another :3gears:
 

tfalk

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 30, 2015
Messages
319
Location
Somerset NJ
Re: New detached garage in the works

Any reason you can't put it at the end of the driveway and attach it to the house? After kicking around a detached garage and all the conditions for it, we've pretty much decided to attach to the house. Might be an option to consider...
 
OP
S

Speedy!

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 23, 2014
Messages
271
Location
TN
Re: New detached garage in the works

Any reason you can't put it at the end of the driveway and attach it to the house? After kicking around a detached garage and all the conditions for it, we've pretty much decided to attach to the house. Might be an option to consider...

Yes that was the first thing I tried. Just connect it to the house and create a breezeway. The problem there was the codes were different for attached and the setback from the property line went from 10 feet to 15 feet meaning I'd lose 5 feet of precious garage width.
 

wyo george

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 24, 2014
Messages
933
Location
Wyoming, USA
Re: New detached garage in the works

Best of luck with your build, seeing stories like this make me glad that I'm the kind of person who likes to live more remote. I just can't wrap my head around having to ask my neighbor if it's OK to put my garage where I want it. I sure hope it works out the way you want it too, your house and property are beautiful BTW.

G
 
OP
S

Speedy!

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 23, 2014
Messages
271
Location
TN
Re: New detached garage in the works

Thank you sir. It's one of the "compromises" to being 20 minutes from work :/
 
OP
S

Speedy!

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 23, 2014
Messages
271
Location
TN
Re: New detached garage in the works

Ok time for an update. They city put a big *** sign in my front yard for a month stating I was asking for a zoning variance. I was expecting a small realtor sign like other cities in the area but seems we're special here LOL This thing was on a 8 foot steel pole with a 3' x 3' steel reflective sign with big red letters "An application has been filed for a zoning appeal". You'd think I was asking to put a ********** in the front yard.

Anyway, paid my $100 application fee, in and out in 8 minutes and got an approval for the variance. Delayed me about 6 weeks, but worth it to have this thing where I want.

Construction should start soon and I'll start posting up pics.

As I'm looking for input, what's the best way on this forum? Start a new thread with specific areas like lighting, air compressor, etc, or just stick them all in this one thread?

Lighting layout is my next area I need to figure out. I'm thinking 12 48" fixtures. I was thinking T8 lamps due to the cost of the T5s and have half on one switch and half on another so I don't have to burn them all unless I need them. Should I do 4 bulb lamps or 2 bulb lamps? I want enough light but don't want to waste money either.
 
Last edited:

NUTTSGT

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Sep 14, 2009
Messages
50,863
Location
Northern Central Ohio
Re: New detached garage in the works

As far as the details go, like compressor or lighting, there have been several threads on these subjects. If you can't find the information you're looking for, simply start a new thread with your questions.

If you choose to update this thread with the build, let me know, I'll move it to the Gallery section. You have provided many details so far in this thread, personally, I continue with the building updates here.
 
OP
S

Speedy!

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 23, 2014
Messages
271
Location
TN
Re: New detached garage in the works

Thanks, have been searching and asking questions in other threads. I will be updating the first post in this thread as the build progresses. I've learned a lot from the build threads here and am happy to put out my experience for others.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom