So with the help of everyone’s feedback, I found a fix to my solution. The original switch is back on and working great. After pulling the switch apart I cleaned up the contacts and the spring. Then took a piece of plastic welding rod, sanded it down appropriately and cut it to proper length. This piece would act as my ‘new’ plunger which worked perfect (the older plunger broke). Reassembled everything. Applied a little dialetric grease to the new homemade plunger and the contact area and it’s good as new! It’s AMAZING how smooth and easily the switch toggles now. Effortlessly. Will say it was a little tricky get the assembly of the switch reattached to the white housing that secures it but wasn’t too bad.
Without a doubt, the culprit of the problem was the gummy stuff that resided inside the switch housing and on the contact strip. I was just waiting for day it would break, it was so stiff. I’m very happy with the outcome. Thank you to everyone!