To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Weekend floor jack

rhp

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 3, 2009
Messages
163
Need something dependable and durable but do not "shop" quality... What floor jack would be a step below the Hein Werner HW93652 3 ton SUV Service Jack for a weekend mechanic?

Does anyone have experience with Arcan (Northern Tools), Omega & AC Delco (O'Reilly's)?
or the
Craftsman 3 ton Aluminum Floor Jack, American Forge and OTC jack (Sears)?


P.S. - Have looked at Torin & HF and not impressed with build quality.
 
Last edited:
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

MotoDave

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 1, 2009
Messages
505
Location
Ventura, CA
I picked up the Arcan low profile unit sold at Costco, there is a thread around here somewhere about it. Very happy with it, especially for under $100 out the door. Has no problems, weight or height wise, lifting my truck.
 

q miester

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 24, 2010
Messages
51
Location
so-cal
I have the craftsman 3 ton aluminum. it works good, just wish it had a sqoosh more height.
 

Auzivision

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 6, 2009
Messages
252
Location
Hoosier State
I have the craftsman 3.5 ton. It works great, but takes a trick to lower slowly. Don't over tighten handle before jacking or the whole thing is going to come crashing down upon release. Only takes 1/8 to 1/4 turn of the handle and down she goes quickly! I don’t know if others are any better.

I also have a real cheap 2 ton portable and the HF 1.5 ton racing jack. The two ton doesn’t have much range and takes a lot of pumping. The HF works better than I expected for being only $49.00 (on sale) and doesn’t weight much.

FloorJack2009009.jpg


OilChange003.jpg
 

Kapn

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 26, 2008
Messages
231
Location
Maryland
I'll 2nd the ARCAN Costco low profile. Had it about a year and no issues. The Craftsman 2.5ton that I got about 7 years ago started leaking down. It eventually got to the point where I couldn't get a jack stand under the car before it would be back on the ground. The replacement parts were much more than a new jack.
 
OP
R

rhp

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 3, 2009
Messages
163
I saw an Arcan Quick Lift Service Jack — 3 1/2-Ton, Model# XL35 (3.5 to 21.38 lift height) at Northern Tools. I was impressed with the U-joint which was beefier than the comparable Torin. I'm just concerned about long term seals dependability.
 

MotoDave

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 1, 2009
Messages
505
Location
Ventura, CA
I saw an Arcan Quick Lift Service Jack — 3 1/2-Ton, Model# XL35 (3.5 to 21.38 lift height) at Northern Tools. I was impressed with the U-joint which was beefier than the comparable Torin. I'm just concerned about long term seals dependability.

That's the same model sold at Costco which I have. Seals have been fine over the past year or so.
 

Hiball

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 30, 2009
Messages
14,027
Location
Missery
I'll 2nd the ARCAN Costco low profile. Had it about a year and no issues. The Craftsman 2.5ton that I got about 7 years ago started leaking down. It eventually got to the point where I couldn't get a jack stand under the car before it would be back on the ground. The replacement parts were much more than a new jack.

Rebuild parts are very cheap... cheap.. for the import jacks of 7 years ago. If you still have that jack check the overload, IF your jack wasnt leaking around the tank nut and was leaking down before you could get stands under it. Well that screams backed off overload.

I saw an Arcan Quick Lift Service Jack — 3 1/2-Ton, Model# XL35 (3.5 to 21.38 lift height) at Northern Tools. I was impressed with the U-joint which was beefier than the comparable Torin. I'm just concerned about long term seals dependability.

I dont know much about these New "Low profile" Arcan, etc... jacks but im fairly confident that they use alot of Orings for sealing surfaces and it will eventually lead to troubles. I cant be for sure because personally ive never been inside one, Im making my assumptions based on there price point.
 

metal1313

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 28, 2009
Messages
3,416
Location
clinton NJ
ive had a 3ton arcan jack from costco for 5-6 years, its not the low profile one they hav now. it has not given me any trouble over those years. it has no problem lifting or holding up my 94bronco or my old f350. for the money i coudlnt be happeier
 
OP
R

rhp

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 3, 2009
Messages
163
Rebuild parts are very cheap... cheap.. for the import jacks of 7 years ago. If you still have that jack check the overload, IF your jack wasnt leaking around the tank nut and was leaking down before you could get stands under it. Well that screams backed off overload.



I dont know much about these New "Low profile" Arcan, etc... jacks but im fairly confident that they use alot of Orings for sealing surfaces and it will eventually lead to troubles. I cant be for sure because personally ive never been inside one, Im making my assumptions based on there price point.

Hiball: I'm glad you checked in. This post was in large part directed to you.

As said in the initial post: Need something dependable and durable but do not need "shop" quality... What floor jack would be a step below the Hein Werner HW93652 3 ton SUV Service Jack for a weekend mechanic working on a '79 Bronco?

Don't want something "cheap" as safety is main concern but I don't need overkill either. Can you suggest something that has high value for the money without breaking the bank?

But, if you're adamant about the Hein Werner HW93652 - 3 ton SUV Service Jack, then I respect your opinion and will save the shekels to eventually buy it.

P.S. Thanks for your telephone time with me last week. Ended up buying Torin 6 ton Double-Locking Jack Stands
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

ImportTuner

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Jan 9, 2007
Messages
5,855
Location
SF Bay Area
Hiball: I'm glad you checked in. This post was in large part directed to you.

As said in the initial post: Need something dependable and durable but do not need "shop" quality... What floor jack would be a step below the Hein Werner HW93652 3 ton SUV Service Jack for a weekend mechanic working on a '79 Bronco?

Don't want something "cheap" as safety is main concern but I don't need overkill either. Can you suggest something that has high value for the money without breaking the bank?

But, if you're adamant about the Hein Werner HW93652 - 3 ton SUV Service Jack, then I respect your opinion and will save the shekels to eventually buy it.

P.S. Thanks for your telephone time with me last week. Ended up buying Torin 6 ton Double-Locking Jack Stands

You can't beat the Hein Werner HW93652 .. excellent quality, reliable, and very solid .. :)
 

Hiball

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 30, 2009
Messages
14,027
Location
Missery
ive had a 3ton arcan jack from costco for 5-6 years, its not the low profile one they hav now. it has not given me any trouble over those years. it has no problem lifting or holding up my 94bronco or my old f350. for the money i coudlnt be happeier

Let me be clear, Im not bashing the Arcan jacks. I dont work for Hein Werner, Milwaukee, Weaver or any other company that makes jacks here in the states. Im giving my opinion based on Real life sitsuation along with customers reviews. I have no idea what seals are used inside that jack, Im speculating that they are in fact Oring and after 6 years of use you are nearing the life expectancy and possibly you have already noticed some of the signs that the seals dont have as much "sealing power" as they used to, Whether its taking more pumps to lift a load or noticing extra oil on the pump shaft. Im glad your happy with your jack.

Hiball: I'm glad you checked in. This post was in large part directed to you.

As said in the initial post: Need something dependable and durable but do not need "shop" quality... What floor jack would be a step below the Hein Werner HW93652 3 ton SUV Service Jack for a weekend mechanic working on a '79 Bronco?

Don't want something "cheap" as safety is main concern but I don't need overkill either. Can you suggest something that has high value for the money without breaking the bank?

But, if you're adamant about the Hein Werner HW93652 - 3 ton SUV Service Jack, then I respect your opinion and will save the shekels to eventually buy it.

P.S. Thanks for your telephone time with me last week. Ended up buying Torin 6 ton Double-Locking Jack Stands

Dependable and Durable??? Lets dig into these 2 words a little deeper, Dependable first.. Most of your import jacks are using a hydraulic system that has been around for around 40-50 years. Its a simple design that works very well, Where the problem lies is that these manufacturers have skimped on seals and they just dont give you the Durablility that you can get from the Major players. If you can deal with some minor rebuilding every 2-6 years and have a outlet for the required parts you can keep these machines in tip top working condition. Durable Now.. There is no one in this forum who is gonna convince me that there Import, Oring sealed Hydraulic jack is just as good as the Major players. They weren't designed to last as long and they wont. Your not gonna get the longevity out of a Buna Oring as you would out of a Leather reiniforced Vee packing or a Poly U cup. Im not gonna argue with people, Its your money and you can spend it however you want. Im not saying that Im right and your Wrong im just giving you the facts. There are many things that play into a consumers decision making process and its just not the Quality of a product, and i fully understand this. This is why i created a Picture aided tutorial on how to rebuild your typical Import jack, I also field 100's of questions a week helping people solve there problems. The HW93652 is great jack, It has 70 years of bloodline with only minimal changes, I would also like to add the 93642 might be a great choice also as its a 2 ton jack and would be plenty enough for your bronco, You do sacrifice a inch or two of lifting height with the step down but still a quality product. I also recommend looking for a quality used jack that is rebuildable. All these options are viable, I do have a problem seeing people spend $200+ dollars on a Import jack when you can get into a 93642 for a few bucks more. I would rather see them invest in a $49 Harbor Freight 2 ton than go that route.

Steven
 
OP
R

rhp

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 3, 2009
Messages
163
Let me be clear, ....
Steven

Thanks for your reply.
The HW93642 is priced reasonably & height is not an issue.

My only concern was a 2 ton jack for the Bronco, but if you feel that it is sufficient then that will be my aim.
 

Chattah

Member
Joined
Mar 4, 2009
Messages
12
I can give a third vote for the ARCAN Costco low profile. I have had it a short while now but am very pleased with it. As always use jack stands so you keep your shirt clear of blood.
 

Hiball

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 30, 2009
Messages
14,027
Location
Missery
Thanks for your reply.
The HW93642 is priced reasonably & height is not an issue.

My only concern was a 2 ton jack for the Bronco, but if you feel that it is sufficient then that will be my aim.

That jack will give you at least 4000lbs of lifting force before the safety valve kicks in, I suspect the Bronco weighs around 5500lbs maybe more or less im not sure but you need to remember that your only lifting the Front or the rear or side and not the whole vehicle. In general people are infactuated with numbers but the have a hard time counting Common Cents. (spelled wrong to emphasis my point) LOL You cant go wrong with the HW 2 ton and if you want a bit more stability you can step up to the 3 ton, It not only has a larger rated tonnage but bigger frame. Check for deals online and even Sears sells Hein Werner Jacks so you might be able to get it shipped to store etc...

I can give a third vote for the ARCAN Costco low profile. I have had it a short while now but am very pleased with it. As always use jack stands so you keep your shirt clear of blood.

Always use jack stands.. Always... Regardless of what type of lifting tool your using.
 
OP
R

rhp

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 3, 2009
Messages
163
That jack will give you at least 4000lbs of lifting force before the safety valve kicks in, I suspect the Bronco weighs around 5500lbs...

It weighs around 5K lb loaded.
It is rated front axle - 3,550 lb; rear axle - 3750 lb.

So the 2 ton should be fine, even when jacking at the pumpkin. Please correct if wrong.
 

Hiball

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 30, 2009
Messages
14,027
Location
Missery
It weighs around 5K lb loaded.
It is rated front axle - 3,550 lb; rear axle - 3750 lb.

So the 2 ton should be fine, even when jacking at the pumpkin. Please correct if wrong.

100% Correct
 

scotte

Well-known member
Joined
May 16, 2007
Messages
133
i've been using a 3 ton torin from tractor supply company at home for 1.5 years on weekend duty and i bought another 3 months ago for my business (daily duty)

i just spent $20 on the 2 year replacment tsc plan on the daily use one

(tsc is down the road from my shop and they stock that model jack)

if it breaks after 2 years i'll buy another
 

benjamming

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 29, 2009
Messages
899
Location
Alabama
What floor jack would be a step below the Hein Werner HW93652 3 ton SUV Service Jack for a weekend mechanic?

Hein Werner 2 ton HW93642. :lol_hitti But seriously, Hein Werner 2 ton HW93642. I'm really not trying to be a smart aleck.
 

1984GMC

Banned
Joined
Jan 2, 2010
Messages
625
Location
Gum Spring,Va.
I've had a craftsman aluminum one for almost 9 years now, when I first got it, Had a problem with the adjustment screws leaking, but once I backed it out and reinstalled it, no more leaks, It is sensitive to getting air in it and causing the pump to only work about 1/2 stroke, after a day or so it goes back to normal.. the weight savings have really made up for the troubles. Its great if you have to carry it around from place to place.
 

StarWolve

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 7, 2009
Messages
104
Location
The Queen City
Thanks for all the input on this thread - I was trying to decide on a Floor Jack myself, and after reading everything here, I decided on this:
IMG_0016.jpg


I got it for a reasonable price locally. I told the guy that if he could beat the cheapest internet site's price (with shipping) after tax, that I'd pay cash. He threw in a set of 3-ton jack stands for another $20. We had a deal, and now I have my jack without having to wait for shipping. I know I spent a lot more than I could have gotten an Arcan unit for, but this will work for my wife's car AND my truck reliably, and I won't have to buy another one, ever. (maybe a rebuild kit, I'm confident in it, but not delusional) After thinking about it, I just couldn't justify something else.

Plus: Made in the USA. I understand that the company maybe owned overseas, but it's MADE HERE.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom