Thanks for the replies everyone, I've been reading them, just haven't had the chance to respond until this morning.
Think of how much more space you'd have without snowblower, snowshovels and winter tires! LOL
Lol seriously!! There are tradeoffs anywhere one chooses to live, but let's just say I'd be perfectly happy if it was warm all year round.
Thanks, Dan. I'm leaning towards this.
I vote option A. Your a busy man and have a family you take care of. Adding preventive maintenance chores to yourself and something else for you to worry over. Option A seems a more sensible route even though Option B seems like it might have more options. Just my .02.
This is true. I could handle the extra maintenance, but I don't really want to. I'm not one to flip cars, I've had this one for 7 yrs and am planning on keeping it for another 7 haha. I guess I'm at a point where I'm trying to refresh my interest in it, though, with the tune and some (hopefully tasteful) cosmetic changes. But at the end of the day you're right, it's a daily driver, needs to be reliable and semi-practical. I agree there is something to be said for less hassle. I'm surprised your Camaro scrapes at stock height, you must have a steep drive!
I’ll give you permission to not worry about the corrosion on the galvanized coilovers, while acknowledging that you’ve ascribed a price of $120/mm to your suspension height. I’m at like $500/hp added to my Alfa so that seems reasonable lol.
I don’t really care about clean cars but I’ve tried Fluid Film and used engine oil as a winter coating for my suspension components on the new cars; it’s decent in Michigan! Any specialty coating recommended by the supplier and an extra 20 minutes per corner when swapping the summer wheels on is probably worth the discount over stainless.
In my opinion, it’s sometimes beneficial to avoid the temptation to hit every problem with the biggest hammer. See how bad the galvanized parts really are for yourself. It’s not like you’re messing around with a water heater or roofing. It’s just your ability to lower or raise your car.
That $650 premium for the coilovers does save you 30-60 minutes per corner on installation time since you won’t be disassembling the assemblies, as you know. I’m not against the work, but an easy installation is worth something when it’s not a passion project
LOL on the $120/mm!! Well when you put it that way...
With taxes and shipping everything factored in, it's more like $80/mm

. It's not as much the price as the value that bothers me, which is what you're getting at.
After doing a lot of reading I've come to the same conclusion about the galvanized bodies, I think there's adequate ways to protect them well enough. I currently use Fluid Film on my suspension and pinch welds before winter. Not sure it's the best thing out there but there are plenty of solutions like that.
The installation bit you pointed out I forgot to mention — I do think that's valid and I'm really not looking forward to the install. Skipping the spring compressors would be great, and not cannibalizing the existing setup (which I could save for later or in case of emergency).
Nick, I can't remember if you are the sole driver of the car. I'm pretty good about stopping short of the tire curbs in the parking lots but my partner is not.
The Eibach springs on the PT Cruiser lowered the chin spoiler a half inch below those curbs. It also lowered the bumper cover enough to scrape on the entrance ramp at our dentist's office. The first bumper cover lasted two years and I got 11 years out of the second but I got real good at pop-riveting it bed back together. Eventually the cover was too badly beaten up to ignore so I pulled the spare out of the attic and painted it (Turbo models have a different cover that was getting hard to find). Before doing the paint job I disassembled the front struts and added a second rubber spacer. The cover now clears the curbs by at least a quarter inch. Here's the obligatory before/after shot.
I'm essentially the sole driver. My wife can drive stick and has driven it a handful of times, but not for some time. I think she doesn't like it as much. Wow, you have the PT Cruiser on springs? Sweet! Nice job on the bumper. My current springs were a 30-35mm (1.2 - 1.4") drop from stock height. I think I'm on the 1.4" end of that. But I never scrape. I wouldn't clear one of those parking curbs, but drive ways, speed bumps, etc are all fine. I just measured and in the front my ground clearance is 5.5", on the sides more like 5", and in the middle the exhaust muffler hangs down a bit and is probably 4" or less.
Ive gotten alot of miles on coilovers over the years. If you want to priotize comfort then you would probably be better off with the VWR setup. You can get a good ride with coilovers but you need to pony up for the higher end setups. Not saying coilovers wont ride well but they definitely stiffen up things, the car will handle fantastic! But you will sacrifice comfort. Ive been running BC coilovers for a few years and really like them. Have some trackdays on them as well but with how the roads are in michigan I sometimes do ponder swapping them out. It is really nice to have the adjustibilty, I have raised and lowered for different wheel setups or seasons before. This was my mk7 when I was running some BBS CK's. I had no rubbing at all at this height.
Thanks for coming through with a real world Mk7 example
Your car looks great. And a two-door

. Also loving the CK's, I assume they are 19's?
That sort of fitment looks great. I think in my head that's what I want (maybe a little less aggressive). As mentioned in other replies I'm leaning towards keeping the VWR setup. If I was in a warm climate with decent roads I think I'd go for it, I'm just not sure it's smart given everything we deal with here in MN.
Out of curiosity which BC Racing coils do you have?
I like lowering springs and a good shock/strut to match. Only had one car with adjustable coilovers and while it did well I didnt have it very low at all due to living at my parents house and their gravel
drive at the time. I hate scraping and rubbing, and have been able to build multiple setups that got me low enough to get the look without sacrificing ride or comfort.
If I did do the coilovers I'd definitely be going lower than the springs. That said like a lot have suggested, I'm leaning towards keeping the springs.
Hi Nick, straight after I bought my T6 I put on 20’s and went to see Steve at CRSperformance
for adjustable coil overs and dropped it 60mm.
Wheels fill the arches better.

Drives way better. It was technically a van to start though and I think I had more height to play with than you.
Steve
Flippin' awesome Steve! I would hope you have more wheel gap to work with than a GTI

. My current drop is 35mm and I can fit one finger comfortably between the tire and fender, if that gives you an idea.
While I probably already know the answer, I'm going to float the idea anyway... have you considered adding a minivan to the fleet that could serve as your winter beater, road trip vehicle for your growing family, and material hauler for your woodworking and house projects? This would allow you to make mods to the GTI without having to worry about the practicality constraints of needing it to serve as a daily driver.
I have absolutely considered that! Well, not a minivan specifically, but a winter vehicle. I don't have anything against minivans whatsoever, I think they serve their purpose fantastically, but I'd probably go for a crossover. The reasons I've shied away from that approach, are.
1/ garage space, in my 18x20 I can't park a large vehicle, a truck is certainly too big and even something like a mini van might be a tight fit
2/ no storage for a 3rd car, I want the car I'm driving in the winter to be in the garage, street parking isn't a good option so the GTI would have to go into a storage facility somewhere
3/ If I was going to make the GTI a summer project car, I'm not sure the GTI is the car for that... I'd maybe look at more of a true sports car or something older
4/ summer is too short and life's too short to drive boring cars, the GTI sees very little miles as is, and I think it would be a shame to drive it even less
I do see this in the picture one day though. Once the kids are out of car seats. I could see getting a more practical car for daily driving, and more of a true sports car / Sunday driver / project car that doesn't see winters. Grail would be a 911 but that's a pipe dream for now.