I just got my sample kit and I'm quite impressed! I've been stalling on my garage makeover for years, mainly because I'm stuck on how to do the flooring. Went down the rabbit holes of epoxy, porcelain, and various composites (both snap together and glued VCT), and they all have a fair number of drawbacks.
I recently came across the New Age product, and it seems perfect for me.
My floor is rough, but fairly flat, with just a couple of 2-3mm high spots that I'll probably spot grind to get "close enough" to flat. Although the tiles are very rigid, there is a bit of backing cushion where I won't have to get too ****.
I assembled my samples on the ground as a test to walk on, and there's definitely a bit of a cushion compared to concrete. It's not much, but you can tell it's there. Not sure if this will permanently compress over the years and lose it's spring, but I'll take it for now!
The tiles seem just slightly clackier than walking on concrete. Like walking across a hardwood floor in sneakers (concrete) vs. dress shoes (New Age floor). Keep in mind this is just on my small test bed; it might dampen once I have the whole floor installed.
I was concerned with how well the tiles would seal against themselves, and if the seam would accumulate dirt or if water would seep through. Ends up they did a nice job with the interconnect. It's very tight, but also seems quite easy to install (might not even need to mallet it too much). The gap between tiles is barely perceptible - dirt should brush right out - and I think I could probably hose the garage out without water getting in between.
Anyway, that's my first impression. Once I figure out the samples I don't want I'll do some destruction tests
By the way, the stuff I do is mainly homeowner stuff and light mechanical/electronic/wood projects. So for me, these are perfect. I'm sure I'll cause some damage over the years, but I'll buy a few extra tiles and replace if needed. It seems like I can use a toilet plunger or something to lift up a small section after they've been installed.
My last point is that I'm quite stoked on the ease of prep, installation, and the non-permanent nature of it. I mean, they look great, I'll get the floor done in literally a weekend, and worst case if it starts falling apart in five years I can just rip 'em up and put something else in without having to grind up epoxy or grout. What's also nice is that I don't have to empty my garage to do this. I can move my stuff to one half, install half, swap, and be done.
Sure, it's not a cheap option. But man, the thought of what I'd have to go through to do epoxy "right" is paralyzing.
Anyway, I won't get to this until winter and I'll post some pics as I'm going through it. I'm very happy to have seen this thread and I hope the folks already putting this down share their thoughts and tips.