OPINIONS WANTED
I bought these hand screws (that always sounds a little obscene) at an estate sale for a very good price. A previously unsuspected streak of Obsessive Compulsive Disorder kicked in once I got started spiffing one up. Before I knew it, the first hand screw was half finished; or so I thought. It was only then that I thought to take pictures of the process.
Picture 1 is the three hand screws I bought that day; a 708 and two 712s.
Picture 2 is a close up showing gunk removal in progress. This is the point I had gotten to when I thought to take pictures. The gunk varied in thickness and consistency. Some of it was oily and some was more like tar. All of it was dirty.
Picture 3 is a close up of two spots where there had been glue which sealed out future layers of grime.
Picture 4 is a before-and-after close up of the threads of the handles. There was gunk there too and it was hard. I had to pick it out little by little. I counted them in case you want to know how many grooves there are on each handle. There's just one, two if you consider that the thread reverses in the middle.
Picture 5 is, of course, before and after.
Here's what I want your opinion on. Did I do too much and change the patina too much? Before you answer, consider this: I did not use sandpaper or a chemical stripper just 0000 steel wool and Boiled Linseed Oil. Where the gunk was thick or especially stubborn, I used a putty knife as a scraper. What do you think? How much is too much? When spiffing up an old tool, where do you personally draw the line? Under what circumstances will you cross the line you set?